# MinistryEngine: full text Last updated 2026-10-25. --- ## MinistryEngine | Church and nonprofit consulting built to last URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/ id="main"> Consulting for churches and Christian-led nonprofits Build something that lasts past you. Your church or nonprofit is growing. The structure under it is thin, and the culture still lives in a few people. We help you name what is true, build the plan and the leaders to carry it, and stay beside you while it multiplies. Book a free call See how the process works We help Christian leaders of growing churches and Christian-led nonprofits who fear what they have built will not outlast them build the foundation, the leaders, and the systems that multiply, so the mission lives beyond the founding generation. What happens if the structure stays thin? A church can grow for years on one person's energy. Then the founding generation tires, a campus drifts, or a gifted leader leaves, and the thing everyone loved turns out to have lived in a few people. The pastors we talk to feel it before they can name it. They are anxious, a little alone, and carrying more than one person should. You do not have to wait for the failure to act on the warning. What is actually wrong in most growing churches? Most churches we meet are living in one of three gaps, and many are in all three. Identity without formation You may know what you believe, but it has never been named clearly, so it has never been built into how people are formed. There is no clear brand, and no belonging infrastructure. Strategy without leadership You have a plan and not yet the people to carry it. Leaders get placed instead of developed. The org chart exists. The growth architecture does not. Community without multiplication You have something good and cannot scale it without losing it. The founding pastor is the culture, and nothing yet reproduces it. Who is MinistryEngine? We lead the way you do, with you. Our three partners have 90 years of combined ministry experience, have built and pastored churches from 500 to 12,000, and every one of us still serves in active ministry today. We are in the foxhole with you. We know the many hats, the Sunday afternoon emails, and the weight of caring for souls while leading through constant change. We also know the joy of baptizing new believers and watching new leaders grow. Most churches piece the work out: one firm for hiring, another for a giving campaign, a consultant for small groups. Those fixes rarely connect to the church's strategy. We start with who you are and what you are building, then help with each need, so the pieces fit and the church lasts. Brad House Managing Partner Doug Schmidt Partner Nick Bogardus Partner Meet the whole team What do we mean by integration? Integration means three things line up: who you are, what you say, and what you do. Identity What your church or nonprofit believes and who it is for. Named clearly, in one place. Words Your communications. How the belief is spoken to attenders, givers, volunteers, staff, and your city. Actions Your operations, staff development, and culture. What people actually experience when they show up. When the three agree, energy compounds and the mission can outlast the founders. When they do not, energy leaks, people sense it, and trust erodes. That is why we start with what you believe and then build the words and the actions to match. How does the work go? Four steps, always in this order. The order is the point. Diagnose An audit shows the real picture and sets the scope. The type fits the project: church and elder health, staff health, or congregational listening. Excavate A Belief Session finds what is already true and records it in a Foundation Document. Team Dynamics and a Strategy Session follow as the project needs. Architect Plans built on that foundation: a Communications Playbook, Leadership Pipeline, Org Chart, Development Plans, and more. Integrate An experienced partner stays in the room: a Fractional Executive Pastor, a Fractional Communications Director, or Executive Coaching. Book a free call Read the full process Not ready for the full process? Start with a cohort . Who do we work with? We have served churches and Christian-led nonprofits including Dutton Farm, Magnify, Northwest Gospel, and Stonegate. Churches Medium to large churches going multisite, adjusting a model, building groups into the engine of growth, or moving through a leadership transition. Christian-led nonprofits Mission-driven organizations that have outgrown their founders' reach and need leaders, strategy, and rhythms that scale. The framework is the same. Which situation sounds like yours? Navigating a leadership transition A church gets through a leadership transition by naming what must survive the change before deciding who leads next, then building the leaders and rhythms so the culture does not depend on the person leaving. Clarifying your message to support growth A church clarifies its message by deciding what the church is for before deciding what to say. Going multisite for the first time A church going multisite keeps its culture by deciding, before the first campus launches, what is non-negotiable at the center and what each site is free to own. Adjusting an existing multisite model A church adjusting its multisite model should first diagnose where it sits between two failures: a franchise, where sites comply without commitment, or fragmentation, where sites own everything and share nothing. Making groups the growth engine Small groups drive growth when they are built as a belonging infrastructure with a clear belief, a leadership ladder, defined outcomes, set spaces and rhythms, and a plan to multiply. Growing a Christian-led nonprofit past its founders A Christian nonprofit builds leaders as it grows by tying leadership development to strategy and to a steady operating rhythm, so decisions move down to the people closest to the work. See every situation we work in What do we believe? Every leader in ministry eventually asks the same question. How do I build something that matters, with people I trust, in a way that lasts? Most of us found out what the opposite looks like first. Several of us on this team spent years under leadership where the convictions, the words, and the actions did not agree, and we watched what that does to people and to a church. The cost does not show up in year one. It shows up in staff who stop trusting the story, in leaders who burn out, and in churches that cannot outlast the person at the center. That sent us on a long search. First, what makes a leader good. Then, harder, what makes an organization good: how a healthy leader builds a church or nonprofit where what it believes, what it says, and what it does all line up: identity, words and communications, actions in operations, staff, and culture. We call that integrity, and we mean more than morals. We mean wholeness. Competency can build something. Integrity is what keeps it standing. What we have learned is that longevity depends on integrity, in the leader and in the organization, both. A whole church can outlast its founder, multiply its leaders, and carry its culture to a campus the founding pastor will never lead. We are not writing this from the sidelines. Every one of us is still serving in active ministry, so we are in the foxhole with you. We know the Sunday afternoon emails and the weight of the work. The church is not yours to hold up alone. It belongs to Christ, and that is why you can afford to build it honestly. The greatest factors for impact in a community are integrity and longevity. These beliefs shape how we work. See the six principles on the process page . What does the other side look like? Pastors move from anxious to confident, because an experienced team is working beside them. From disappointed to hopeful, because the transition has a path. From stuck to moving, because the next step is clear. And the church moves from depending on the founders to reproducing them: leaders, groups, and campuses that carry the culture without you in the room. Book a free call Questions people ask What is MinistryEngine? MinistryEngine is a consulting firm for churches and Christian-led nonprofits. It helps leaders build the identity, leaders, and systems that last, using a five-stage method called the Integrated Team Process. Who does MinistryEngine work with? Lead pastors, executive pastors, elder boards, and the leaders of Christian-led nonprofits. Most church clients are medium to large churches, especially churches going multisite for the first time, adjusting a multisite model, or building groups into the engine of growth. What is the Integrated Team Process? It is MinistryEngine's five-stage method: Diagnose, On-ramp, Excavate, Architect, and Integrate. The sequence matters, because each stage makes the next one productive. How is MinistryEngine different from hiring separate consultants? Most churches hire one firm for staffing, another for a giving campaign, and a third for ministry advice. Those solutions rarely connect to the church's strategy. MinistryEngine starts with identity and strategy and then helps with each need, so the pieces fit. Where do I start? Book a free call. Most churches then begin with the Church Health Audit, which is a low-cost way to see the real picture and scope what comes next. --- ## The Integrated Team Process | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/process/ id="main"> What is the Integrated Team Process? The Integrated Team Process is MinistryEngine's five-stage method for helping a church build something that lasts: Diagnose, On-ramp, Excavate, Architect, and Integrate. The stages run in order because each one makes the next one productive. What does each stage do? 1 Diagnose Where are we, honestly? 2 On-ramp Who needs to grow first? 3 Excavate Who are you? 4 Architect How do you build it? 5 Integrate How do you sustain it? The five stages and what they produce Stage Question it answers What you get Diagnose Where are we, honestly? Church and Nonprofit Health Audit On-ramp Who needs to grow first? MinistryEngine Cohorts Excavate Who are you? The Belief Session , The Team Dynamics Session Architect How do you build it? The Strategic Playbook , The Communications Playbook , The Leadership Playbook , Organizational Design and the Org Chart , Community Architecture Integrate How do you sustain it? Executive Partnership Standalone services, available at any time: Crisis Communications , Church Staffing , and Giving and Capital Campaigns . Why does the sequence matter? The phases are sequential by design. Strategy built before identity devolves into manipulation, because you end up asking what you have to say to get people to do what you want. Leadership systems built before strategy produce leaders who are developed but not directed. Community built before identity produces warmth without direction. Every shortcut produces a downstream failure. The Health Audit exists to create urgency for the Belief Session. The Belief Session exists to make the Architect work productive. The Architect work exists to make the Integrate work meaningful. What principles run through every engagement? Identity before architecture You cannot build what you have not named. Every engagement starts with excavation, because strategy built on an unexamined foundation does not hold. Formation over information The question is not what we believe but who we are becoming. Culture is built through repeated practice inside real relationship, not through content delivery. Structure serves the mission, or it consumes it Every organization drifts toward institutionalization unless someone intervenes. Structure that has stopped serving the mission is the enemy. Belonging requires cost and practice Community comes from practicing values together. Shared language, rites of passage, spaces, and rhythms are how culture is passed on. Multiplication is the proof of health A healthy leader develops the next leader. A healthy church plans the next community. If the system is not reproducing, it is consuming. Local ownership requires a non-negotiable center You need a center strong enough to hold identity across distance and edges free enough to allow local ownership. Get it wrong and you get a franchise or fragmentation. What is the process not? It is not a menu of unrelated services. It is not a workshop you attend and forget. It is not a plan handed over at the end with no one to help carry it out. And it does not promise outcomes from a single step: results come from the Architect and Integrate work built on a real foundation, not from one session alone. Book a free call Questions people ask What is the Integrated Team Process? The Integrated Team Process is MinistryEngine's five-stage method for churches: Diagnose, On-ramp, Excavate, Architect, and Integrate. Each stage makes the next one productive. Why does the sequence matter? Strategy built before identity drifts toward manipulation. Leadership systems built before strategy produce leaders who are developed but not directed. Community built before identity produces warmth without direction. Do I have to do every stage? No. Smaller churches often stop at a cohort. Architect work requires a Health Audit and a Belief Session first. Crisis Communications, Church Staffing, and Giving Campaigns can be engaged on their own. Who is the process for? It is for lead pastors, executive pastors, elder boards, and the leaders of Christian-led nonprofits. The same framework serves both. --- ## Diagnose: Integrated Team Process stage 1 | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/process/diagnose/ id="main"> What is the Diagnose stage? Diagnose is the first stage of the Integrated Team Process. It is a documented look at where your church or nonprofit honestly stands. The audit fits the project: a church and elder health audit across multisite systems, leadership pipeline, culture, mission alignment, attendance, giving, and staff health; a staff health audit; or a congregational listening process. Why does this stage matter? Most churches start by fixing the loudest problem. The Health Audit shows the real one, and it sets the scope for everything that follows. It is required before any Architect work. What do you get? Church and Nonprofit Health Audit A documented gap analysis of your church, and a recommended path forward. On-ramp Book a free call Questions people ask What is the Diagnose stage? Diagnose is the first stage of the Integrated Team Process. It is a documented look at where your church or nonprofit honestly stands. The audit fits the project: a church and elder health audit across multisite systems, leadership pipeline, culture, mission alignment, attendance, giving, and staff health; a staff health audit; or a congregational listening process. Why does Diagnose come first? Most churches start by fixing the loudest problem. The Health Audit shows the real one, and it sets the scope for everything that follows. It is required before any Architect work. What does the Church Health Audit cover? It covers multisite systems, leadership pipeline, culture, mission alignment, attendance, giving, and staff health. --- ## On-ramp: Integrated Team Process stage 2 | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/process/on-ramp/ id="main"> What is the On-ramp stage? On-ramp is the stage for leaders who are not ready for full engagement yet. MinistryEngine Cohorts bring leaders together around a shared topic, tailored to your ministry context. Why does this stage matter? For a smaller church a cohort is a complete engagement. For a larger church it feeds the rest of the process by building shared language before the heavier work begins. What do you get? MinistryEngine Cohorts Small-group learning for church leaders who are not ready for full engagement. Diagnose Excavate Book a free call Questions people ask What is the On-ramp stage? On-ramp is the stage for leaders who are not ready for full engagement yet. MinistryEngine Cohorts bring leaders together around a shared topic, tailored to your ministry context. Why does On-ramp come at this point in the process? For a smaller church a cohort is a complete engagement. For a larger church it feeds the rest of the process by building shared language before the heavier work begins. What topics do MinistryEngine Cohorts cover? Cohorts cover small groups, multisite, communications, pastors' wives, and church leadership teams, tailored to the context of each group. --- ## Excavate: Integrated Team Process stage 3 | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/process/excavate/ id="main"> What is the Excavate stage? Excavate is the stage where we find what is already true about your church. The Belief Session is creative archaeology. We do not manufacture meaning. We dig up the conviction, values, purpose, and vision that are already there and hand them back in a form you can build on. The stage can include a Belief Session, a Team Dynamics Session, and a Strategy Session, because a foundation your leaders cannot work from together is not a foundation yet. Why does this stage matter? Identity comes before architecture. A strategy built on an unexamined foundation does not hold, so the Belief Session always comes before Architect work. And competency is not enough: the most talented team in the room loses to a team with deeper trust and clearer identity. What do you get? The Belief Session Creative archaeology that produces your Foundation Document. The Team Dynamics Session Three sessions that show how your leaders are wired and how they work together. On-ramp Architect Book a free call Questions people ask What is the Excavate stage? Excavate is the stage where we find what is already true about your church. The Belief Session is creative archaeology. We do not manufacture meaning. We dig up the conviction, values, purpose, and vision that are already there and hand them back in a form you can build on. The stage can include a Belief Session, a Team Dynamics Session, and a Strategy Session, because a foundation your leaders cannot work from together is not a foundation yet. Why does Excavate come at this point in the process? Identity comes before architecture. A strategy built on an unexamined foundation does not hold, so the Belief Session always comes before Architect work. And competency is not enough: the most talented team in the room loses to a team with deeper trust and clearer identity. What is a Belief Session? A Belief Session is a half-day or full-day session where MinistryEngine helps a church leader or leadership team find what is already true about their identity, and records it in a Foundation Document. What is the Team Dynamics Session? The Team Dynamics Session is a three-part working session, led by Nick and Kim Bogardus, that helps a church team understand how each leader is wired, see the strengths and weaknesses of the team as a group, and practice the behaviors of a healthy team. --- ## Architect: Integrated Team Process stage 4 | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/process/architect/ id="main"> What is the Architect stage? Architect is the stage that turns the Foundation Document into plans and structures. The work includes the Strategic Playbook, the Communications Playbook, leadership pipeline and development plans, organizational design and the org chart, and Community Architecture. Together they answer where we are going, how we speak, who will take us there, and what belonging will sustain us. Why does this stage matter? This stage produces plans, structures, and systems. It also produces alignment, the moment everyone in the room finally sees how the pieces fit. What do you get? The Strategic Playbook The plan: communications, organization, campus strategy, and goals. The Communications Playbook How your church speaks, built to support the strategy and not to run beside it. The Leadership Playbook The structure: a leadership pathway, development plans, and operating rhythms. Organizational Design and the Org Chart Roles, structure, and authority, for now and for the next season. Community Architecture The belonging infrastructure that lets groups drive your growth. Excavate Integrate Book a free call Questions people ask What is the Architect stage? Architect is the stage that turns the Foundation Document into plans and structures. The work includes the Strategic Playbook, the Communications Playbook, leadership pipeline and development plans, organizational design and the org chart, and Community Architecture. Together they answer where we are going, how we speak, who will take us there, and what belonging will sustain us. Why does Architect come at this point in the process? This stage produces plans, structures, and systems. It also produces alignment, the moment everyone in the room finally sees how the pieces fit. What is the Strategic Playbook? The Strategic Playbook is a 60 to 90 day engagement that produces a written plan covering communications, organization, campus strategy, audience messaging, and goals. What is the Communications Playbook? It is a MinistryEngine deliverable that defines how a church or nonprofit speaks: brand archetype, messaging architecture, and audience messaging. What is the Leadership Playbook? It is a 6 to 12 month engagement that produces a leadership pathway, personal development plans, 360 feedback, and operating rhythms for a church. What is Organizational Design? It is the work of building an org chart with role descriptions and decision rights that fit a church or nonprofit's mission and season. What is Community Architecture? Community Architecture is a MinistryEngine engagement that produces the belonging infrastructure for a church, answering six questions about belief, ownership, outcome, leadership ladder, spaces and rhythms, and multiplication. --- ## Integrate: Integrated Team Process stage 5 | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/process/integrate/ id="main"> What is the Integrate stage? Integrate is the ongoing stage. The Executive Partnership places an experienced partner in the room across four layers: strategic, narrative, people, and belonging. In practice that means a Fractional Executive Pastor, a Fractional Communications Director, executive coaching and leadership development, or a Community Architect. Why does this stage matter? Integrate is not the end of the process. It is the work of keeping everything aligned as the church moves and changes. This is where the work compounds. What do you get? Executive Partnership An experienced partner in the room, across four layers of your church. Architect Book a free call Questions people ask What is the Integrate stage? Integrate is the ongoing stage. The Executive Partnership places an experienced partner in the room across four layers: strategic, narrative, people, and belonging. In practice that means a Fractional Executive Pastor, a Fractional Communications Director, executive coaching and leadership development, or a Community Architect. Why does Integrate come at this point in the process? Integrate is not the end of the process. It is the work of keeping everything aligned as the church moves and changes. This is where the work compounds. What is the Executive Partnership? It is an annual engagement with four tracks: Fractional Executive Pastor, Fractional Communications Director, Leadership Development, and Community Architect. --- ## Church and Nonprofit Health Audit | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/health-audit/ id="main"> What is the Church and Nonprofit Health Audit? The Church and Nonprofit Health Audit is a structured review of seven areas: multisite systems, leadership pipeline, culture, mission alignment, attendance, giving, and staff health. It produces a written gap analysis and sets the scope for any work that follows. Stage 1: Diagnose Who is this for? Lead pastors, executive pastors, elder boards, and the leaders of Christian-led nonprofits who sense something is off and cannot yet name it, or who are about to invest in a large decision and want an honest picture first. What do you get? A health audit report that names the gaps in plain language A recommended engagement path, so you know what to do next and in what order How does it work? Share the picture You give us the numbers and context for attendance, giving, staffing, and structure. We assess We review the seven areas and look for where they disagree with each other. You get the report We walk you through the gap analysis and the recommended path. Book a free call Questions people ask What does the Church Health Audit cover? It covers multisite systems, leadership pipeline, culture, mission alignment, attendance, giving, and staff health. What do I receive at the end of the Health Audit? You receive a documented health audit report and a recommended engagement path. Do I have to do the Health Audit before other work? Yes for Architect work. The Health Audit is required before any Architect engagement, because it sets the scope. Who is the Health Audit for? It is for lead pastors, executive pastors, elder boards, and Christian-led nonprofit leaders, including churches going multisite. --- ## MinistryEngine Cohorts URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/cohorts/ id="main"> What are MinistryEngine Cohorts? MinistryEngine Cohorts bring church leaders together around one topic for a defined season. Topics include small groups, multisite, communications, pastors' wives, and church leadership teams, and each is tailored to the ministry context of the people in the room. Stage 2: On-ramp Who is this for? Leaders and teams who want guided help without a full consulting engagement. Smaller churches often find a cohort is all they need. Larger churches use cohorts to build shared language before deeper work. What do you get? Completion of the cohort with peers in similar seasons An individual leadership action plan How does it work? Choose a topic Pick the cohort that matches your role or your church's next question. Work it together You meet with other leaders and practice the material in real context. Leave with a plan Each leader finishes with an action plan for their own ministry. Book a free call Questions people ask What topics do MinistryEngine Cohorts cover? Cohorts cover small groups, multisite, communications, pastors' wives, and church leadership teams, tailored to the context of each group. Is a cohort a complete engagement? For smaller churches, yes. For larger churches a cohort also feeds into the rest of the Integrated Team Process. What do I leave a cohort with? You leave with cohort completion and an individual leadership action plan. --- ## The Belief Session | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/belief-session/ id="main"> What is the Belief Session? The Belief Session is a half-day or full-day working session with a leader or a leadership team, and it includes a Team Dynamics Session led by Nick and Kim Bogardus. For many engagements it extends into a Strategy Session, so the Foundation Document and the plan start together. It is not a workshop. It is creative archaeology: we excavate what is already true about your church and hand it back as a Foundation Document that holds your conviction, values, purpose, vision, and campaign narrative. Stage 3: Excavate Who is this for? Churches that preach one thing and sense the culture says another. Teams that are talented and not aligned. Any church about to build strategy on a foundation nobody has examined. What do you get? A Foundation Document: conviction, values, purpose, vision, and campaign narrative The Team Dynamics Session, which shows how your leaders are wired and how they actually work together A foundation you own. It belongs to the church and travels with you into any later work. How does it work? Prepare We learn your history, your people, and what you have already said about who you are. Excavate In the session we dig for the belief your church embodies, which is sometimes different from the one it preaches. Hand it back You receive the Foundation Document in a form you can build on. Book a free call Questions people ask What is a Belief Session? A Belief Session is a half-day or full-day session where MinistryEngine helps a church leader or leadership team find what is already true about their identity, and records it in a Foundation Document. What is in the Foundation Document? The Foundation Document holds your conviction, values, purpose, vision, and campaign narrative. Why does the Belief Session come before strategy? Strategy built before identity drifts toward manipulation. Identity comes before architecture, so the Belief Session always precedes Architect work. Who owns the Foundation Document? The church owns it. It belongs to the client and travels with them into any later engagement. Is the Belief Session a workshop? No. It is creative archaeology. We do not manufacture meaning. We uncover what is already true. --- ## The Team Dynamics Session | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/team-dynamics/ id="main"> What is The Team Dynamics Session? The Team Dynamics Session is part of the Excavate stage, led by Nick and Kim Bogardus. Competency is not enough, so we look at the people carrying the vision. Over three sessions your leaders learn their own wiring through the Enneagram, see the strengths and gaps of the team as a group, and practice the five behaviors of a healthy team. Each team receives a Team Dynamics Playbook prepared for them. Stage 3: Excavate Who is this for? Church staff teams and elder boards that are talented and not aligned, teams with a new leader or a new member, and any team about to build a plan together on top of a shared foundation. What do you get? A Team Dynamics Playbook prepared for your team A self-awareness statement for each leader: how people experience them when they are at their best and at their worst A group portrait of how others experience your team, and what they will not experience until you change A short list of practices your team commits to, built around the five behaviors of a healthy team How does it work? Know your wiring Session one is an overview of the Enneagram. The purpose is to understand your wiring, the impact you have on others, and to gain empathy for the people around you. You are more than a number, and self-awareness works with story. See the team Session two shows your team's results and names the group's strengths and weaknesses. Each person shares their self-awareness statement, and the team writes how others experience them as a whole. Build the behaviors Session three teaches the building blocks of a healthy team and asks which behavior is hardest for each person, and what practices the team will put in place. Book a free call Questions people ask What is the Team Dynamics Session? The Team Dynamics Session is a three-part working session, led by Nick and Kim Bogardus, that helps a church team understand how each leader is wired, see the strengths and weaknesses of the team as a group, and practice the behaviors of a healthy team. Is it part of the Belief Session? Yes. The Team Dynamics Session belongs to the Excavate stage and is included with the Belief Session. Why does MinistryEngine look at team dynamics before strategy? Because competency is not enough. A team that has a plan and lacks trust and shared identity underperforms a less talented team that has both. Do you use the Enneagram? Yes, in session one, as a way to build self-awareness and empathy. We treat it as a doorway into a person's story, not as a label. You are more than a number. Who leads the Team Dynamics Session? Nick Bogardus and Kim Bogardus lead it together. --- ## The Strategic Playbook | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/strategic-playbook/ id="main"> What is the Strategic Playbook? The Strategic Playbook is a 60 to 90 day engagement that turns your Foundation Document into a plan. It covers communications strategy, organizational strategy, campus and site strategy, messaging for your key audiences (attenders, givers, volunteers, staff, and community), and a goals framework. For multisite churches it includes campus launch strategy and site-level ownership models. Stage 4: Architect Who is this for? Churches with a clear identity and no clear plan, and multisite churches deciding how to launch the next campus or share ownership with the sites they have. What do you get? The Plan, written to be used and not filed Audience messaging for attenders, givers, volunteers, staff, and community A goals framework your team can run weekly Strategy your communications can finally serve, instead of running on their own How does it work? Anchor We start from your Foundation Document so the plan serves who you are. Build We develop strategy across communications, organization, and campuses. Hand off You receive the Plan and a goals framework your team owns. Book a free call Questions people ask What is the Strategic Playbook? The Strategic Playbook is a 60 to 90 day engagement that produces a written plan covering communications, organization, campus strategy, audience messaging, and goals. Do I need a Belief Session first? Yes. The Playbook is built on the Foundation Document, because strategy without identity drifts toward manipulation. Why pair communications with the Strategic Playbook? Communications without a strategy turns haphazard and siloed. The Playbook gives communications something to support, so the story told outside the church matches the plan inside it. Does it include campus launch strategy? For multisite churches, yes. It includes campus launch strategy and site-level ownership models. --- ## The Communications Playbook | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/communications-playbook/ id="main"> What is The Communications Playbook? The Communications Playbook turns your Foundation Document into how your church speaks: brand archetype, messaging architecture, and messaging for your key audiences. In a season of transition it includes healing-transition communications such as FAQ language, elder talking points, and rumor response. It is built alongside the Strategic Playbook, because communications without a strategy turns haphazard and siloed. Stage 4: Architect Who is this for? Churches and ministries whose communication is constant and confusing, teams with a communications director in transition, and any leadership team that wants its words to match its beliefs and its actions. What do you get? A clear brand and messaging architecture Audience messaging for attenders, givers, volunteers, staff, and community A communications structure and rhythm your team can run How does it work? Start from the foundation We begin with your Foundation Document and your strategy. Build the message We define the voice, the messages, and who speaks to whom. Equip the team We hand over the playbook and coach the people who will run it. Book a free call Questions people ask What is the Communications Playbook? It is a MinistryEngine deliverable that defines how a church or nonprofit speaks: brand archetype, messaging architecture, and audience messaging. Why build it with the Strategic Playbook? Because communications without a strategy turns haphazard and siloed. The strategy gives communications something to support. Does it help during a leadership transition? Yes. It can include healing-transition communications such as FAQ language, elder talking points, and rumor response. --- ## The Leadership Playbook | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/leadership-playbook/ id="main"> What is the Leadership Playbook? The Leadership Playbook is a 6 to 12 month engagement that builds the people infrastructure to carry the plan. It maps a leadership pathway from volunteer to staff to senior leader (the leadership pipeline), creates personal development plans for the executive pastor and senior team, adds 360 feedback and assessment, and sets operating rhythms: the annual calendar, the weekly cadence, and decision-making frameworks. Stage 4: Architect Who is this for? Churches with a plan and a thin bench. Executive pastors who are carrying too much. Boards that know the founding generation will not lead forever. What do you get? The Structure: a documented leadership pathway Personal development plans and 360 feedback for your senior team Operating rhythms that make good habits the default How does it work? Assess We take stock of your leaders through assessment and 360 feedback. Design We build the pathway, the development plans, and the rhythms. Practice Over months, your team practices the rhythms until they hold without us. Book a free call Questions people ask What is the Leadership Playbook? It is a 6 to 12 month engagement that produces a leadership pathway, personal development plans, 360 feedback, and operating rhythms for a church. Why does it take 6 to 12 months? Because formation happens through repeated practice inside real relationship. Knowing what to do is not the same as being formed to do it consistently. Who is the Leadership Playbook for? It is for executive pastors, senior teams, and elder boards who need to develop leaders and not just place them. --- ## Organizational Design and the Org Chart | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/org-design/ id="main"> What is Organizational Design and the Org Chart? Organizational Design builds the org chart with role descriptions, decision rights, and structure for your current season and the next one, including interim and future-state versions when a leader is leaving. It is where the Leadership Playbook's pathway meets the real shape of your staff. Stage 4: Architect Who is this for? Churches and ministries that grew by relationship and need structure that matches the mission, and teams in transition who need to know who decides what. What do you get? An org chart with role descriptions Clear authority and decision rights Interim-state and future-state structures when a transition is underway How does it work? Map what is We document how the organization actually runs today. Design what is next We draw roles, reporting lines, and authority to serve the mission. Install it We help you move people into the structure with clarity and care. Book a free call Questions people ask What is Organizational Design? It is the work of building an org chart with role descriptions and decision rights that fit a church or nonprofit's mission and season. Can you design an interim structure? Yes. During a leadership transition we can build both an interim-state and a future-state structure. --- ## Community Architecture | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/community-architecture/ id="main"> What is Community Architecture? Community Architecture is MinistryEngine's own work, drawn from Brad House's books Community and MultiChurch. It answers six questions: What is the belief that makes this community worth forming? Who owns it? What is the defined outcome? What is the leadership ladder? What are the spaces and rhythms? How does it multiply? The result is the belonging infrastructure that makes a church's community life sustainable and scalable without losing coherence. Stage 4: Architect Who is this for? Churches that need small groups to be the driving force of growth, and multisite churches that need each site to feel like one church. What do you get? The Belonging Infrastructure, documented A leadership ladder from participant to group leader to coach A multiplication plan so groups and sites reproduce How does it work? Name the belief We start with the belief that makes your community worth joining. Build the ladder We design ownership, outcomes, spaces, rhythms, and the leadership ladder. Plan multiplication We build the system that produces the next leader and the next group. Book a free call Questions people ask What is Community Architecture? Community Architecture is a MinistryEngine engagement that produces the belonging infrastructure for a church, answering six questions about belief, ownership, outcome, leadership ladder, spaces and rhythms, and multiplication. Where does Community Architecture come from? It is drawn from Brad House's books Community: Taking Your Small Group Off Life Support and MultiChurch: Exploring the Future of Multisite. What is the belonging infrastructure? It is the documented system of shared language, spaces, rhythms, and leadership that lets a church's community life grow without losing coherence. --- ## Executive Partnership | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/executive-partnership/ id="main"> What is the Executive Partnership? The Executive Partnership is an annual engagement. You choose one track, combine several, or embed all four. The Fractional Executive Pastor track is embedded multisite counsel and strategic advice to the lead pastor and elder team. The Fractional Communications Director track holds your voice and brand, campaign and series communications, and crisis communications, and we pair it with strategy work, because communications without a strategy turns haphazard and siloed. The Leadership Development track provides executive coaching, executive pastor coaching, staff training, and pipeline development. The Community Architect track sustains and multiplies your belonging infrastructure, and is led by Brad House in most engagements. Stage 5: Integrate Who is this for? Churches that finished the Architect work and need a partner in the room, and churches that need senior help now and cannot yet afford a full-time hire. This service was previously listed as Fractional Leadership. What do you get? A partner in the room when direction gets set and leaders get stuck A known annual cost and priority access Alignment kept intact as the church moves and changes How does it work? Choose your tracks Pick one layer or combine several. Embed Your partner joins key meetings and works alongside your staff. Keep aligning Each season we check that strategy, people, story, and community still agree. Book a free call Questions people ask What is the Executive Partnership? It is an annual engagement with four tracks: Fractional Executive Pastor, Fractional Communications Director, Leadership Development, and Community Architect. Is this the same as Fractional Leadership? Yes. The service formerly called Fractional Leadership now lives in the Integrate stage as the Executive Partnership. Can I hire a fractional communications director without strategy work? We recommend pairing them. Communications exists to support a strategy, and without one it turns haphazard and siloed. If your church has no strategy yet, we start with the Belief Session and Strategic Playbook so communications has something to carry. Can I choose just one track? Yes. You can choose one track, combine several, or embed all four. Who leads the Community Architect track? Brad House leads it in most engagements. --- ## Crisis Communications | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/crisis-communications/ id="main"> What does Crisis Communications include? Crisis Communications is a standalone service. It is not tied to a stage, because crises do not wait for your sequence. Nick Bogardus leads it, drawing on public relations and media relations work at Mars Hill Church and Belief Agency and on his years leading marketing and leadership development at Subsplash. It covers crisis communications planning before something happens and execution when it does. Standalone service, available at any time Who is this for? Churches facing a leadership failure, a public controversy, or media attention, and churches that want a plan in place before they need one. What do you get? A communications plan for the moment, written with your leaders Clear voice and message for staff, members, and the public How does it work? Call us Tell us what is happening. Stabilize We set the message, the owners, and the sequence of communication. Recover We help you rebuild trust once the moment passes. Book a free call Questions people ask What does Crisis Communications include? It includes crisis communications planning before an event and execution during one, for staff, members, and the public. Do I need the Integrated Team Process to use it? No. Crisis Communications is standalone and can be engaged at any time. --- ## Church Staffing | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/church-staffing/ id="main"> What does Church Staffing include? Church Staffing is MinistryEngine's retained and outsourced recruiting service, run by MinistryEngine partners, with Kim Bogardus on team fit. It helps churches find leaders who fit the church's identity and strategy, and is strongest when it follows a Belief Session, because you know who you are looking for. Standalone service, available at any time Who is this for? Churches hiring an executive pastor, campus pastor, or other senior role, and churches that cannot afford a failed hire. What do you get? A search run to your strategy and identity Candidates assessed for team fit How does it work? Define the role We tie the role to your strategy and Foundation Document. Search We source and screen candidates. Place We support the decision and the first season. Book a free call Questions people ask What kinds of roles does Church Staffing fill? It supports senior church roles such as executive pastors and campus pastors, through retained and outsourced search. Why connect staffing to the Belief Session? A search is stronger when you know who you are. The Foundation Document tells us what to look for. --- ## Giving and Capital Campaigns | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/giving-campaigns/ id="main"> What are Giving and Capital Campaigns? Giving and Capital Campaigns are led by Greg Gibbs, author of Capital Campaign Playbook and Creating a Culture of Generosity, who has consulted on more than 150 capital campaigns. The work ties the campaign to your church's strategy and story so generosity grows from conviction and not from pressure. Standalone service, available at any time Who is this for? Churches planning a building project, a campus launch, or a season of generosity. What do you get? A campaign tied to your strategy A culture of generosity that outlasts the campaign How does it work? Align We connect the campaign to your vision. Plan We design the campaign and communications. Run We guide you through the campaign. Book a free call Questions people ask Who leads giving campaigns at MinistryEngine? Greg Gibbs leads them. He is the author of Capital Campaign Playbook and has consulted on more than 150 capital campaigns. Are campaigns tied to the rest of the process? Yes. We tie campaigns to your strategy, so the campaign serves the mission and does not stand apart from it. --- ## Services | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/services/ id="main"> What does MinistryEngine offer? MinistryEngine offers five stages of church consulting plus three standalone services. Each service below belongs to a stage of the Integrated Team Process, or stands alone. 1. Diagnose Church and Nonprofit Health Audit A documented gap analysis of your church, and a recommended path forward. 2. On-ramp MinistryEngine Cohorts Small-group learning for church leaders who are not ready for full engagement. 3. Excavate The Belief Session Creative archaeology that produces your Foundation Document. The Team Dynamics Session Three sessions that show how your leaders are wired and how they work together. 4. Architect The Strategic Playbook The plan: communications, organization, campus strategy, and goals. The Communications Playbook How your church speaks, built to support the strategy and not to run beside it. The Leadership Playbook The structure: a leadership pathway, development plans, and operating rhythms. Organizational Design and the Org Chart Roles, structure, and authority, for now and for the next season. Community Architecture The belonging infrastructure that lets groups drive your growth. 5. Integrate Executive Partnership An experienced partner in the room, across four layers of your church. Standalone services Crisis Communications Planning and response when your church is in the news or in trouble. Church Staffing Retained and outsourced recruiting for church leadership roles. Giving and Capital Campaigns Campaigns and generosity culture, led by an author with 150+ campaigns. --- ## Situations | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/situations/ id="main"> Which situation sounds like yours? Most of our clients arrive in one of these situations. Start with the one closest to yours. Navigating a leadership transition How does a church get through a leadership transition well? Clarifying your message to support growth How does a church clarify its message so it supports growth? Going multisite for the first time How does a church go multisite without losing its culture? Adjusting an existing multisite model What should a church do when its multisite model is not working? Making groups the growth engine How do small groups become the engine of church growth? Growing a Christian-led nonprofit past its founders How does a Christian nonprofit build leaders as it grows? Funding the next chapter How does a church fund its next chapter without straining its mission? --- ## Navigating a leadership transition | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/situations/leadership-transition/ id="main"> How does a church get through a leadership transition well? A church gets through a leadership transition by naming what must survive the change before deciding who leads next, then building the leaders and rhythms so the culture does not depend on the person leaving. MinistryEngine uses a Health Audit, a Belief Session, the Leadership Playbook, and Church Staffing, with an Executive Partnership to steady the season. What does this feel like? A founding or longtime leader is leaving, has left, or has not yet named a timeline. Staff are watching. Members are anxious. The elders know the decision in front of them will shape the next twenty years, and nobody on the team has done this before. What is usually going on? Transitions expose whether the culture lives in a person or in the church. If it lives in a person, the transition is a crisis. If it lives in shared identity and a leadership pipeline, it is a handoff. The work is to move from the first to the second before, and during, the change. What does the work look like? Church and Nonprofit Health Audit A documented gap analysis of your church, and a recommended path forward. The Belief Session Creative archaeology that produces your Foundation Document. The Leadership Playbook The structure: a leadership pathway, development plans, and operating rhythms. Church Staffing Retained and outsourced recruiting for church leadership roles. Executive Partnership An experienced partner in the room, across four layers of your church. Book a free call Questions people ask When should a church start planning a leadership transition? As early as possible. Naming what must survive the change is much easier before the handoff than during it. What does MinistryEngine do during a pastoral transition? We assess the church with a Health Audit, name its identity in a Belief Session, build the leadership pathway, help with the search, and can stay as an Executive Partner through the first season. --- ## Clarifying your message to support growth | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/situations/clarifying-your-message/ id="main"> How does a church clarify its message so it supports growth? A church clarifies its message by deciding what the church is for before deciding what to say. Communications without a strategy turns haphazard and siloed, so MinistryEngine pairs a Belief Session and a Strategic Playbook with a Fractional Communications Director who carries the story into every channel. What does this feel like? You are communicating constantly: services, series, campaigns, social, email. And none of it adds up. Different ministries tell different stories. Staff and members are unsure what the church is trying to do, and communications keeps getting asked to fix a problem it cannot see. What is usually going on? This is rarely a communications problem. It is a strategy problem that shows up in communications. When there is no shared answer to who we are and where we are going, every channel invents its own. Siloed messages are the symptom. What does the work look like? The Belief Session Creative archaeology that produces your Foundation Document. The Strategic Playbook The plan: communications, organization, campus strategy, and goals. Executive Partnership An experienced partner in the room, across four layers of your church. Book a free call Questions people ask Why is our church communication confusing? Usually because the church has no shared strategy for communications to support, so each ministry and channel tells its own story. Can MinistryEngine just fix our communications? We can, and we recommend pairing it with strategy work. Communications that supports a plan drives growth. Communications that stands alone stays haphazard. --- ## Going multisite for the first time | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/situations/going-multisite/ id="main"> How does a church go multisite without losing its culture? A church going multisite keeps its culture by deciding, before the first campus launches, what is non-negotiable at the center and what each site is free to own. MinistryEngine does this with a Health Audit, a Belief Session, and a Strategic Playbook that includes campus launch strategy and site-level ownership. What does this feel like? The first campus is exciting. Then the questions arrive. Will it feel like us? Who leads it? What do we decide centrally and what do we hand over? You have a vision for the second site and no tested model for holding the first one together. What is usually going on? Most first-time multisite churches have strong identity and no system that carries it. The culture lives in the founding pastor. Distance exposes that. A site cannot copy a person. What does the work look like? Church and Nonprofit Health Audit A documented gap analysis of your church, and a recommended path forward. The Belief Session Creative archaeology that produces your Foundation Document. The Strategic Playbook The plan: communications, organization, campus strategy, and goals. Community Architecture The belonging infrastructure that lets groups drive your growth. Book a free call Questions people ask When should a church start planning multisite? Before the first launch. Decisions about what stays central and what sites own are far harder to make after campuses exist. What does MinistryEngine do for a church going multisite? We run a Health Audit, a Belief Session to name the non-negotiable center, and a Strategic Playbook with campus launch strategy and site-level ownership models. --- ## Adjusting an existing multisite model | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/situations/adjusting-multisite-model/ id="main"> What should a church do when its multisite model is not working? A church adjusting its multisite model should first diagnose where it sits between two failures: a franchise, where sites comply without commitment, or fragmentation, where sites own everything and share nothing. A Health Audit and Belief Session name the center, and the Strategic and Leadership Playbooks rebuild the structure around it. What does this feel like? You launched the sites. Now the sites drift, or the center is stretched thin, or local leaders feel like employees of headquarters. The model worked at two campuses and strains at five. What is usually going on? Local ownership needs a non-negotiable center. Too much center gives you a franchise. Too little gives you fragmentation. The fix is rarely more control. It is a clearer center and freer edges. What does the work look like? Church and Nonprofit Health Audit A documented gap analysis of your church, and a recommended path forward. The Belief Session Creative archaeology that produces your Foundation Document. The Strategic Playbook The plan: communications, organization, campus strategy, and goals. The Leadership Playbook The structure: a leadership pathway, development plans, and operating rhythms. Book a free call Questions people ask How do I know if my multisite model needs adjusting? Common signs are drifting site culture, a stretched central team, and local leaders who feel like employees instead of owners. Is the answer more central control? Usually not. The answer is a clearer non-negotiable center and more freedom at the edges. --- ## Making groups the growth engine | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/situations/groups-as-growth-engine/ id="main"> How do small groups become the engine of church growth? Small groups drive growth when they are built as a belonging infrastructure with a clear belief, a leadership ladder, defined outcomes, set spaces and rhythms, and a plan to multiply. MinistryEngine builds this through Community Architecture, drawn from Brad House's work scaling groups from 35 to more than 600. What does this feel like? You have groups. Some are healthy. Most depend on one gifted leader. Participation plateaued, and every new group requires you to find another gifted leader. What is usually going on? Groups multiply when the system produces leaders, not when a program recruits them. If the system is not reproducing, it is consuming. Multiplication is the proof of health. What does the work look like? Church and Nonprofit Health Audit A documented gap analysis of your church, and a recommended path forward. Community Architecture The belonging infrastructure that lets groups drive your growth. The Leadership Playbook The structure: a leadership pathway, development plans, and operating rhythms. Executive Partnership An experienced partner in the room, across four layers of your church. Book a free call Questions people ask What makes small groups scale? A leadership ladder that produces new leaders, clear ownership, defined outcomes, and spaces and rhythms that repeat. Where does MinistryEngine's group work come from? From Brad House's book Community: Taking Your Small Group Off Life Support and his work growing community groups from 35 to more than 600. --- ## Growing a Christian-led nonprofit past its founders | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/situations/scaling-ministry-leadership/ id="main"> How does a Christian nonprofit build leaders as it grows? A Christian nonprofit builds leaders as it grows by tying leadership development to strategy and to a steady operating rhythm, so decisions move down to the people closest to the work. MinistryEngine does this with a Strategic Playbook that sets a long-range vision and a quarterly roadmap, and a Leadership Playbook that builds the pathway and the rhythms. What does this feel like? The mission is strong and the staff believe in it. The organization has grown, and the executive team is still in decisions that belong to directors. Directors care deeply and were promoted without tools. Teams work in silos, priorities compete, and budget season arrives without a strategic frame to guide it. What is usually going on? Promoting from within without development, or sending leaders to generic training, builds temporary knowledge and no lasting capacity. The fix is connected: strategy, leadership pathway, and operating rhythms designed together, so each supports the others. What does the work look like? Church and Nonprofit Health Audit A documented gap analysis of your church, and a recommended path forward. The Belief Session Creative archaeology that produces your Foundation Document. The Strategic Playbook The plan: communications, organization, campus strategy, and goals. The Leadership Playbook The structure: a leadership pathway, development plans, and operating rhythms. Executive Partnership An experienced partner in the room, across four layers of your church. Book a free call Questions people ask Does MinistryEngine work with Christian-led nonprofits, not only churches? Yes. The Integrated Team Process is one framework for both. The vocabulary, the cases, and a few products change, and the order does not. What does leadership development look like for a growing nonprofit? A competency framework from program manager to executive across character, knowledge, scope, and complexity, a shared leadership language rooted in the mission, and operating rhythms such as weekly leadership meetings and quarterly and annual planning. --- ## Funding the next chapter | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/situations/funding-the-next-chapter/ id="main"> How does a church fund its next chapter without straining its mission? A church funds its next chapter by tying the campaign to strategy, so people give to a vision they already understand and own. MinistryEngine pairs a giving or capital campaign led by Greg Gibbs with the strategy and story work that makes the ask make sense. What does this feel like? You are approaching a ceiling: full services, a building that no longer fits, debt that limits your options, or a campus you want to launch. The budget will not carry the vision, and a campaign without a clear story feels like pressure. What is usually going on? Generosity follows conviction. Campaigns struggle when the church has not named where it is going, so the ask arrives before the reason. The money question is almost always a strategy question first. What does the work look like? Church and Nonprofit Health Audit A documented gap analysis of your church, and a recommended path forward. The Strategic Playbook The plan: communications, organization, campus strategy, and goals. Giving and Capital Campaigns Campaigns and generosity culture, led by an author with 150+ campaigns. Book a free call Questions people ask When should a church start a capital campaign? After it can say clearly where it is going and why. A campaign tied to a named strategy raises more and costs less trust. Who leads giving campaigns at MinistryEngine? Greg Gibbs, who has consulted on more than 150 capital campaigns. --- ## About and team | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/about/ id="main"> Who is MinistryEngine? MinistryEngine is a consulting firm for churches and Christian-led nonprofits, led by Brad House, Doug Schmidt, and Nick Bogardus. Our three partners have 90 years of combined ministry experience, and every one of us still serves in active ministry today. What do we believe? The greatest factors for impact in a community are integrity and longevity. Why do we exist? We exist to advance and encourage churches during seasons of challenge, as a single place to find affordable, personal help with the hard questions of ministry. Who is on the team? Brad House Managing Partner | Multisite strategy and community Nick Bogardus Partner | Strategic and crisis communications, adaptive leadership Kim Bogardus Executive Coach | Executive coaching, team dynamics, and staffing Doug Schmidt Partner | Plural leadership and governance Gregg Allison Advisor | Governance, polity, and theology GG Greg Gibbs Giving and capital campaigns Phil Goodman People Health | Staff health, HR strategy, and team trust Jesse Bryan Belief Session Facilitator | Belief Session and church identity Book a free call Questions people ask Does MinistryEngine publish prices? Pricing depends on scope. The first conversation is free, and we scope the Health Audit or the next step with you. Who leads MinistryEngine? Brad House is Managing Partner, and Doug Schmidt and Nick Bogardus are partners. Kim Bogardus, Jesse Bryan, Phil Goodman, and Greg Gibbs are on the team, with Gregg Allison as an advisor. --- ## Brad House, Managing Partner | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/team/brad-house/ id="main"> Brad House Managing Partner | Multisite strategy and community Brad House brings two decades of senior leadership experience to churches working through growth and multiplication. He is the author of Community: Taking Your Small Group Off Life Support (Crossway) and co-author of MultiChurch: Exploring the Future of Multisite (Zondervan). He served as Senior Executive Pastor of Strategy and Integration at Woodside Bible Church, sat on the board of directors at Mars Hill Church during its growth across 14 locations, served as President and Collective Director of Sojourn Community Church's six-church collective, and as Vice President and Chairman of the Harbor Network church planting network. He scaled community groups from 35 to more than 600, with 70 percent participation, and led a full organizational restructuring while reaching record financial health. Book a free call --- ## Nick Bogardus, Partner | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/team/nick-bogardus/ id="main"> Nick Bogardus Partner | Strategic and crisis communications, adaptive leadership Nick Bogardus has more than 20 years of experience driving growth across entertainment, B2B software, and ministry. As Senior Vice President of Marketing and Leadership Development at Subsplash, he led marketing and leadership development as the company grew from $47M to $65M in annual recurring revenue (ARR). He founded and pastored two churches, served as PR and Media Relations Director at Mars Hill Church in Seattle, and worked as a PR and Media Relations Specialist at Belief Agency. He has taught as an adjunct professor at Biola University and served as Pastor-in-Residence for its Center for Christian Thought. Book a free call --- ## Kim Bogardus, Executive Coach | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/team/kim-bogardus/ id="main"> Kim Bogardus Executive Coach | Executive coaching, team dynamics, and staffing Kim Bogardus is an executive coach who specializes in leadership development and team dynamics. She holds a Masters-level certification in Executive Coaching and Counseling from the John Townsend Institute at Concordia University and a BA from Azusa Pacific University. As a church planter alongside her husband, she built leadership programs for elders' wives and deacons. She has spoken at The Gospel Coalition, Harbor Network, and local church events, and now coaches leaders and leads workshops across marketplace and ministry settings. Book a free call --- ## Doug Schmidt, Partner | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/team/doug-schmidt/ id="main"> Doug Schmidt Partner | Plural leadership and governance Doug Schmidt holds BA, MBE, and EdD degrees. After seven years as a seminary professor and Dean of Students, he pastored Ross Bible Church of Port Huron for five years, then became senior pastor of Woodside Bible Church in 1991. Under his leadership Woodside grew from one location to 14 campuses. Book a free call --- ## Gregg Allison, Advisor | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/team/gregg-allison/ id="main"> Gregg Allison Advisor | Governance, polity, and theology Gregg Allison is Professor of Christian Theology at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, secretary of the Evangelical Theological Society, and book review editor for theological, historical, and philosophical studies at the Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society. He is the author of 27 books, including MultiChurch: Exploring the Future of Multisite (with Brad House), Embodied: Living as Whole People in a Fractured World, and Raising the Dust: "How-To" Equip Deacons to Serve the Church. Book a free call --- ## Greg Gibbs, MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/team/greg-gibbs/ id="main"> Greg Gibbs Giving and capital campaigns GG Greg Gibbs is a pastor, author, and consultant with a career in the church of more than 30 years. He wrote Capital Campaign Playbook: A Church Consultant's Gameplan and Creating a Culture of Generosity: A Field Guide for Church Leaders, and has consulted on more than 150 capital campaigns. He serves as Executive Pastor at Vintage Church LA in Santa Monica, California. Book a free call --- ## Phil Goodman, People Health | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/team/phil-goodman/ id="main"> Phil Goodman People Health | Staff health, HR strategy, and team trust Phil Goodman brings Chief People Officer expertise to organizations that need it without the overhead of a full-time hire. He leads the people-health side of the work: staff health, manager effectiveness, psychological safety, and trust in leadership. His work gives a board or leadership team an objective picture of staff health before any personnel decisions are made, followed by a prioritized 90-day people roadmap. Book a free call --- ## Jesse Bryan, Belief Session Facilitator | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/team/jesse-bryan/ id="main"> Jesse Bryan Belief Session Facilitator | Belief Session and church identity Jesse Bryan is the founder of Belief Agency, named Best Agency in Seattle ten consecutive years. He has led brand identity and narrative clarity work for the Seattle Seahawks, Amazon, Microsoft, and dozens of other organizations, as well as churches working through complex identity and communication challenges. He leads the Belief Session for MinistryEngine: the creative archaeology that surfaces what is already true about a church or organization and hands it back in a form the next generation of leaders can build on. Book a free call --- ## Glossary | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/glossary/ id="main"> What do MinistryEngine's terms mean? These are the terms we use with churches, defined in plain language. Integrated Team Process MinistryEngine's five-stage method for churches: Diagnose, On-ramp, Excavate, Architect, and Integrate. The stages are sequential by design. Team Dynamics Session Three working sessions in the Excavate stage, led by Nick and Kim Bogardus: how each leader is wired, how the team functions as a group, and the five behaviors of a healthy team. Included with the Belief Session. Competency is not enough A conviction behind the process: skills, systems, and strategy matter, but they sit downstream of identity, character, and trust. Integration Alignment between a church or nonprofit's identity, its words (communications), and its actions (operations, staff, and culture development). When the three line up, energy compounds. When they do not, energy leaks. Creative archaeology How MinistryEngine describes the Belief Session. We do not manufacture meaning. We excavate what is already true. Identity before architecture The principle that the Belief Session always comes before Architect work. Foundation Document The Belief Session deliverable: a church's conviction, values, purpose, vision, and campaign narrative. The church owns it. Formation over information The distinction between teaching that informs and systems that form people over time through practice. The belonging infrastructure The deliverable of Community Architecture: the documented system of belief, ownership, outcomes, leadership ladder, spaces, rhythms, and multiplication that makes community sustainable. Multiplication is the proof of health The principle that a healthy leader, group, or church reproduces. If a system is not reproducing, it is consuming. The culture travels The test for a multisite church: whether its identity holds at a campus the founding pastor will never lead. Local ownership, non-negotiable center The balance between a strong shared identity and local freedom. Too much center creates a franchise. Too little creates fragmentation. Strategy without leadership A diagnosis: a church has a plan but not the leaders to carry it. Identity without formation A diagnosis: a church knows what it believes but has not built systems to form people around it. Community without multiplication A diagnosis: a church has something good but cannot scale it without losing it. --- ## Frequently asked questions | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/faq/ id="main"> What do churches ask before they call? Short answers to the questions we hear most. Common questions What is MinistryEngine? MinistryEngine is a consulting firm for churches and Christian-led nonprofits. It helps leaders build the identity, leaders, and systems that last, using a five-stage method called the Integrated Team Process. Who does MinistryEngine work with? Lead pastors, executive pastors, elder boards, and the leaders of Christian-led nonprofits. Most church clients are medium to large churches, especially churches going multisite for the first time, adjusting a multisite model, or building groups into the engine of growth. What is the Integrated Team Process? It is MinistryEngine's five-stage method: Diagnose, On-ramp, Excavate, Architect, and Integrate. The sequence matters, because each stage makes the next one productive. How is MinistryEngine different from hiring separate consultants? Most churches hire one firm for staffing, another for a giving campaign, and a third for ministry advice. Those solutions rarely connect to the church's strategy. MinistryEngine starts with identity and strategy and then helps with each need, so the pieces fit. Where do I start? Book a free call. Most churches then begin with the Church Health Audit, which is a low-cost way to see the real picture and scope what comes next. Does MinistryEngine publish prices? Pricing depends on scope. The first conversation is free, and we scope the Health Audit or the next step with you. Who leads MinistryEngine? Brad House is Managing Partner, and Doug Schmidt and Nick Bogardus are partners. Kim Bogardus, Jesse Bryan, Phil Goodman, and Greg Gibbs are on the team, with Gregg Allison as an advisor. --- ## Free church AI use policy template | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/resources/ai-use-policy/ id="main"> Does your staff know how your church uses AI? A free AI use policy template for church staff, adapted from the policy Woodside Bible Church wrote for all 13 of its campuses. Grounded in Scripture and ready for your leadership team to make its own. Get the free template What does the research say? Your staff is already using AI. The question is whether they are working from your convictions or making it up as they go. 94% of Protestant pastors say a church should have a formal AI policy or informal guidelines. Barna, October 2026 79% say their own church has neither. Barna, October 2026 24% of pastors use AI to write or edit sermons. Barna, October 2026 10% feel positive about AI providing spiritual counseling. Barna, October 2026 83% of church leaders say they are concerned about data privacy with AI. Barna and Pushpay, March 2026 The convictions are there. They just have not been written down, which means staff cannot see them, follow them, or be held to them. Sources: Barna Group, Pastors Say Churches Need AI Guidelines. Few Have Them. (October 6, 2026), an online survey of 442 U.S. Protestant pastors in December 2025. Barna Group and Pushpay, How Church Leaders Are Using AI (And What Concerns Them Most) (March 26, 2026), a survey of 1,306 U.S. church leaders in November and December 2025. What is in the template? Guiding principles, starting with "AI is a tool, not a pastor," with Scripture behind the strongest claims Where staff can use AI: editing, administration, research and design Where they cannot: pastoral care and crisis response, confidential information, doctrinal statements, and anything published without human review A plain rule for sensitive data, and what is safe to use Disclosure, human review and theological review expectations Notes for multisite churches on what stays central and what each campus owns Six steps to adopt it, from naming an owner to taking it to your elders Get the free template Your name Email Church Church size (weekend attendance) Choose one Under 500 500 to 1,000 1,000 to 2,500 2,500 to 5,000 5,000 to 12,000 Over 12,000 Send me the template We email you the link and open it on the next page. We never share your details. Questions people ask Should a church have a formal AI policy or informal guidelines? Pastors are nearly split. Barna found 45 percent favor a formal policy and 49 percent favor informal guidance only. This template is written as a formal policy. If you want something lighter, keep the sections on guiding principles, prohibited uses and pastoral care intact and simplify the rest. Who should approve a church AI policy? Your elders or board. Doctrinal authority sits with them (Titus 1:9; Acts 20:28), so they should approve the policy, not simply be told about it. Is the template really free? Yes. Tell us where to send it and the link comes to your inbox and opens on the next page. If you want help adapting it, a Discovery Call is free too. Want help making it work? If your leadership team wants help adapting the policy, training your staff or building the decision-making around it, we would welcome the conversation. Book a free Discovery Call --- ## Editorial policy | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/editorial-policy/ id="main"> How does MinistryEngine decide what to publish? Everything on this site is written or approved by a named MinistryEngine partner. This page explains how. Who writes and approves content? Content is drafted by MinistryEngine partners or by staff working from partner material, and each page is reviewed by a partner before it is published. Articles carry the name of the partner who stands behind them. What do we use as sources? We write from direct engagement experience, from the published work of our team, and from named external sources that we link. We do not publish statistics without a named source. When we describe a pattern from our own work, we say it is a pattern from our experience and not a measured result. How do we use AI? AI tools may help draft or structure text. A person reviews and edits every published page, checks claims against their source, and is accountable for the result. How do we handle corrections? If you find an error, tell us on the contact page . We correct it and update the date shown on the page. Last reviewed 2026-10-25. --- ## Verified facts | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/verified-facts/ id="main"> What are the verified facts about MinistryEngine? This page lists the facts about MinistryEngine we stand behind. Last reviewed 2026-10-25. Facts about MinistryEngine What it is A consulting firm for churches and Christian-led nonprofits Website https://www.ministryengine.com Leaders Brad House (Managing Partner), Doug Schmidt (Partner), Nick Bogardus (Partner) Method The Integrated Team Process: Diagnose, On-ramp, Excavate, Architect, Integrate Standalone services Crisis Communications, Church Staffing, Giving and Capital Campaigns Who it serves Lead pastors, executive pastors, elder boards, and the leaders of Christian-led nonprofits Clients named with permission Dutton Farm, Magnify, Northwest Gospel, Stonegate Combined ministry experience 90 years across the three partners (Doug Schmidt 50, Brad House 20, Nick Bogardus 20) Service area United States Pricing Scoped per engagement. First call is free. --- ## For AI agents and assistants | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/for-ai-agents/ id="main"> How should an AI assistant describe MinistryEngine? MinistryEngine is a consulting firm for churches and Christian-led nonprofits that uses a five-stage method, the Integrated Team Process, to help churches build lasting identity, leadership, and community systems. What is the one-sentence description? We help Christian leaders of growing churches and Christian-led nonprofits who fear what they have built will not outlast them build the foundation, the leaders, and the systems that multiply, so the mission lives beyond the founding generation. What should be cited? Cite the specific page for the specific claim. The process is at /process/ , each service has its own page under /services/ , and facts we stand behind are at /verified-facts/ . Where are the machine-readable files? /llms.txt , a short guide to the site /llms-full.txt , the full text of the key pages /sitemap.xml What should an assistant not claim? Do not state prices, guarantees, or outcome percentages. Pricing is scoped per engagement. Do not describe any single step as producing full organizational results. --- ## 12 Churches, 1 Year, 33% Growth (Here's What Happened) | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/12-churches-1-year-33-growth-heres-what-happened/ id="main"> 12 Churches, 1 Year, 33% Growth (Here's What Happened) What happens when churches do the deeper work of organizational health and community impact? Twelve Michigan pastors showed us. By Nick Bogardus | Published 2025-06-16 | Updated 2025-06-16 What happens when churches move beyond surface-level fixes to address the deeper work of organizational health and community impact? Earlier this month, we sat in a room with twelve pastors from across Michigan, listening to reports that frankly blew us away. These weren't your typical ministry updates. They were transformation stories that challenged everything I thought I knew about sustainable church growth. The denomination's Executive Director leaned over halfway through and whispered, "I wish I had videoed every single report." Here's what we witnessed. The Numbers That Demand Attention Let's start with the metrics every pastor tracks: 33% attendance growth across participating churches in one year. Not launch year growth, but sustainable growth in established churches. Baptisms increased dramatically across the board. In one rural Michigan church of 43 people, 16 baptisms in twelve months. One church went from being known as "the church with no children" to 140 on Sundays with 200 on Easter , and yes, they now have children. But here's what struck us: these weren't churches chasing growth tactics. They were churches that had done the deeper work first. The Leadership Breakthrough That Changes Everything The most powerful transformations happened in the pastors themselves. A seasoned pastor finally gained clarity about succession planning, just before facing a kidney transplant and major health challenges. The strategic process helped him realize he wasn't the right person to lead the church into the future, and he made the transition with grace and wisdom. Another pastor, in a moment of frustration, "told his board off." When he shared this with his coach, the right questions led him to brokenness, confession, and apology. That moment of humility reset his entire leadership approach and became a game-changer for his church. Two other pastors faced boards that dishonored them. Instead of retaliating or resigning, they responded with poise and humility, and emerged as stronger, more respected leaders. The truth is: sustainable church growth requires sustainable pastoral leadership. These pastors weren't just implementing programs; they were becoming the leaders their churches needed for the long haul. The Community Transformation That Redefines Mission The story that brought tears to our eyes came from Pastor Paul in northern Michigan. His church sits in a township of 583 people. When Hurricane damage hit North Carolina, Paul felt called to take a truck full of hay to help rural victims. Church members donated money and supplies, but something unexpected happened: unbelievers in the community wanted to contribute. They were planning a second trip when ice storms devastated their own area. The mission shifted to their neighbors. Paul bought a chainsaw, and for twelve days with no power, he and his team: Cleared roads for the entire community Cleaned up the library Delivered free firewood Provided water from their church's generator For twelve straight days, their church became the community's lifeline. The result? Sixteen baptisms in a church of 43 people. Community members now reach out to Paul for funerals, weddings, and spiritual needs. They've moved from being a church in the community to being a church for the community. The Strategic Foundation That Makes It Sustainable Here's what separates these stories from temporary ministry wins: each church worked through a comprehensive strategic process that addressed: Leadership pipeline development (because the key to lasting impact is longevity) Community engagement strategy (moving from church-focused to community-focused mission) Honoring the past while moving forward (essential for established churches) Working through God's power, not human effort (the spiritual foundation that sustains everything else) These weren't random improvements or lucky breaks. They were the predictable result of churches that got strategic about both internal health and external mission. The Generational Reset That Surprised Everyone Perhaps the most encouraging theme: pastors who were ready to tap out rediscovering vision and passion. One pastor had wondered if he was "done." After working through the strategic process, he presented an innovative plan for using a pavilion he'd built to reach the community through creative outreaches and events. His energy and vision were infectious. This challenges the narrative that established pastors are stuck in their ways. When given the right framework and support, experienced leaders often become the most effective agents of transformation. What This Means for Your Church If you're leading a growing church or multisite organization, these stories reveal something critical: sustainable growth requires more than excellent programming and weekend experiences. The churches that experienced lasting transformation focused on: Leadership development that goes deeper than skill-building Community engagement that creates genuine impact Strategic alignment between values, vision, and execution Systems that work through transitions and challenges The Integration Challenge Here's the tension many of us face: we know our churches need strategic development, but we're already running multiple campuses, managing complex systems, and trying to maintain momentum. The key insight from these twelve churches: strategic work isn't separate from ministry work. It's what makes ministry work sustainable. When you align your values, clarify your purpose, cast compelling vision, and create integrated strategy, everything else becomes more effective. Your weekend experiences improve because they're connected to clear purpose. Your leadership development accelerates because it's tied to strategic vision. Your community impact multiplies because it flows from organizational health. The Path Forward These transformation stories didn't happen by accident. They resulted from churches that committed to the disciplined work of strategic alignment, and had the coaching support to see it through. The question isn't whether your church needs this kind of foundational work. The question is when you'll prioritize it. Because the key to lasting impact is longevity. And longevity requires the kind of strategic foundation these twelve churches built. Ready to explore what strategic transformation could look like in your context? Our Strategic Compass Playbook helps you align values, purpose, vision, and strategy in a focused two-day workshop designed specifically for growing churches and multisite organizations. Plus, ongoing Leadership Coaching ensures you have the support to navigate the implementation challenges that inevitably arise. The pastors whose stories I shared didn't transform their churches alone. They had a framework and a coach. Learn more about Strategic Compass & Leadership Coaching Because sustainable growth requires sustainable leadership. And sustainable leadership requires strategic clarity. --- ## High Growth Required a New Strategy | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/high-growth-required-a-new-strategy/ id="main"> High Growth Required a New Strategy When Crosspointe Christian Church outgrew its operating model, an assessment and two days of onsite planning turned a growth ceiling into a three-year plan. By Nick Bogardus | Published 2025-03-23 | Updated 2025-03-23 When Crosspointe Christian Church reached out to our team, they were experiencing what many successful churches face: the growing pains of their own effectiveness. Over the previous few years, they had seen significant numerical growth that, while encouraging, had created new challenges that threatened to stall their momentum. The Hidden Challenge of Success Crosspointe's growth trajectory had brought them to a critical inflection point. What initially appeared as success was creating structural and strategic constraints: Space Limitations : Their worship center was approaching capacity, with children's areas already maxed out during peak services Leadership Bottlenecks : The pastoral team was stretched thin handling increased pastoral care needs and administrative demands Systems Strain : Volunteer teams, particularly in children's ministry, were struggling to maintain quality with increasing numbers Strategic Uncertainty : Leadership was debating on whether to focus on facility expansion, launching additional services, or exploring multi-site options This "success plateau" is a common but often overlooked challenge in church development. Crosspointe had effectively outgrown their operational model without yet establishing the next phase of ministry infrastructure. Bridging Assessment and Action Our two-phase approach was specifically designed to address this growth barrier: Phase 1: Diagnostic Assessment The leadership survey revealed that while 93% of respondents highly recommended Crosspointe (indicating strong ministry quality), there were emerging inconsistencies in how growth should be managed. The survey exposed differing perspectives on: Prioritization of facility needs versus program expansion The balance between deepening discipleship and broadening outreach How to maintain their close-knit community feel while accommodating more people The best pathway for developing new leaders to support expansion Phase 2: Strategic Breakthrough During our two days of onsite strategic planning, we helped Crosspointe's leadership team: Confront Reality : Acknowledge the limitations of their current model while celebrating its effectiveness Align Vision : Develop consensus around a "faithful, fruitful, and multiplying" future Break Constraints : Design a phased approach that would systematically address space, leadership, and systems bottlenecks Create Immediate Momentum : Establish Q1 priorities focused on space optimization and Easter service expansion The Growth Barrier Solution The resulting strategic plan directly addressed Crosspointe's growth ceiling with specific initiatives: Capacity Expansion : Optimizing their current facility for 80 additional seats and expanding children's ministry capacity by 20% Service Multiplication : Testing a three-service model at Easter with a plan for permanent implementation based on feedback Leadership Development : Beginning intentional elder candidate identification and strengthening the Community Group structure Systems Enhancement : Improving visitor follow-up processes and volunteer recruitment pathways Vision Clarity : Articulating their distinctive niche as "Biblical exposition, intentional shepherding, and an engaged community in a family-centric environment" Transformative Results By addressing both the visible and invisible barriers to growth, Crosspointe is now positioned to move from stuck to scaling. Their three-year strategy provides them with the incremental steps to: Increase worship and ministry capacity without sacrificing quality or community Develop new leaders through intentional identification and preparation Create clear pathways for member engagement through enhanced Community Group structures Lay the groundwork for potential multi-site expansion or church revitalization partnerships As one of the team noted during our final session: "We've been working harder but not necessarily smarter. Now we have both the clarity and the pathway to break through our current limitations." Is your church experiencing the plateau that often follows successful growth? Our specialized assessment and strategic planning process is designed to help churches like yours identify and overcome the specific barriers that keep you from your next level of ministry impact. Contact us to learn how we can help transform your growth ceiling into a new foundation for expansion. --- ## Start Strong, Prepare for Growth | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/start-strong-prepare-for-growth/ id="main"> Start Strong, Prepare for Growth Growth without wisdom quickly becomes a liability. Five areas where wise decisions this year position your church for sustainable, long-term impact. By Nick Bogardus | Published 2024-12-31 | Updated 2024-12-31 As economists forecast brighter days ahead for 2025, church leaders face a unique moment of opportunity. But as a team who have helped lead some of America's fastest-growing and leading multisite churches, we can tell you that growth without wisdom quickly becomes a liability rather than an asset. Think of it this way: rapid growth without proper leadership development creates something like a tree that grows tall too quickly without developing deep roots, vulnerable to toppling in strong winds. That's why at ministryengine, we help churches make strategic decisions that lead to sustainable, healthy growth. Let's explore five crucial areas where wise decision-making in 2025 can position your church for long-term impact: 1. Staff Development and Structure Your team is your most valuable asset for sustainable growth. One of the most counterintuitive truths we've learned is that while growth can come from a skilled communicator, it cannot be maintained by one. Sustainable growth requires: Systematic leadership identification and development Patient, intentional processes for building new leaders Clear pathways for emerging leaders to gain experience Metrics that prioritize health over just numbers 2. Mission-Driven Decision Making The "ghost of that's how we've always done it" haunts many church boardrooms. Breaking free requires: Understanding the drivers behind your current growth Resisting pragmatic shortcuts that promise quick wins Building systems that can adapt as circumstances change Fighting the temptation to cater to consumeristic tendencies 3. Strategic Planning with Longevity in Mind The key to lasting impact in a community is longevity. This means: Balancing growth metrics with discipleship depth Creating sustainable ministry models Building strong organizational foundations Investing in long-term community presence 4. Operational Excellence Seminary gives pastors a theological foundation but often leaves gaps in crucial leadership skills. Consider: Investing in coaching for organizational leadership Developing strong financial management practices Building effective staff management systems Creating clear decision-making processes 5. Cultural Engagement Strategy 2025 brings unique opportunities, particularly with Gen Z showing increased openness to spirituality. Prepare by: Understanding your cultural moment Building authentic community engagement Creating clear pathways for spiritual seekers Developing sustainable evangelism strategies How ministryengine Can Help Having helped guide multiple churches through significant transitions, including complex situations like multisite church mergers, we understand the challenges of navigating growth while maintaining health. Our approach combines: Deep pastoral experience Proven strategic insight Long-term partnership Practical wisdom for implementation The decisions you make in 2025 will shape your church's impact for years to come. Whether you're considering a major transition, planning for growth, or seeking to build stronger foundations, we're here to help you make decisions that lead to lasting impact. Let's make 2025 a year of wise decisions and sustainable growth for your church. Contact us today to explore how we can help your church thrive in this next season. --- ## Finish Strong, Start Fresh: Part 3: Empower Your Team for a Successful Start in 2025 | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/finish-strong-start-fresh-part-3-empower-your-team-for-a-successful-start-in-2025/ id="main"> Finish Strong, Start Fresh: Part 3: Empower Your Team for a Successful Start in 2025 Great plans go nowhere if your team is not equipped, motivated, and accountable. A checklist for clarity, support, and accountability in the new year. By Nick Bogardus | Published 2024-11-04 | Updated 2024-11-04 In this season you and your team are probably spending a lot of time, energy, and resources preparing for your Christmas services. However, we want to remind you of another important opportunity you should balance in the mix. After you've reviewed the past year, set a clear vision, and aligned your resources and goals, it's time to bring your team fully into the process. The best vision and plans will go nowhere if your leadership team isn't equipped, motivated, and accountable. In this final part of our series, we'll outline a checklist to ensure that your staff and volunteer leaders have the clarity, support, and accountability they need to make 2025 your church's best year yet. 1. Set Expectations and Accountability Structures What it is: Clear expectations and regular check-ins are the backbone of effective teamwork and accountability. When everyone knows what they're working toward and how they'll be held accountable, your ministry can move forward with focus and unity. Checklist: Establish Clear Goals for Each Leader: Schedule individual meetings with key staff members to set specific, measurable goals for 2024. These goals should align with the church's broader vision and mission while addressing each leader's unique area of responsibility. Create a Rhythm of Check-ins: Decide on a regular schedule for check-ins (weekly, monthly, or quarterly) to review progress on goals. This provides opportunities for support, feedback, and course correction. Identify Accountability Partners: For multisite churches, consider appointing an accountability partner or "go-to" person at each campus. This person can help ensure consistency in vision execution and provide a touchpoint for you as the senior leader. Pro Tip: Use a shared tool (like Bloom Growth, Asana, Trello, or a simple Google Doc) to track goals and progress. This allows everyone to stay informed and makes accountability easy to maintain. We have found Bloom Growth helpful in both our church and business. These structures and rhythms are things we can help you and your team develop or refine. 2. Equip and Empower Your Leaders What it is: To turn vision into reality, your leaders need training, encouragement, and practical resources. Empowered leaders feel valued, supported, and motivated to carry out their responsibilities effectively. Checklist: Host a Leadership Vision Kickoff Event: Start the new year with an all-staff retreat or a leadership kickoff event to inspire your team around the 2025 vision. This is a chance to set a positive tone, build excitement, and provide key updates. Offer Ongoing Development Opportunities: Invest in your leaders with training opportunities, whether through conferences, workshops, or online courses. Leadership development not only benefits your team but also strengthens the church as a whole. Address Emotional and Spiritual Health Needs: Ministry can be draining, and burnout is real. Encourage leaders to prioritize their spiritual health and personal boundaries. Consider providing resources for personal renewal, such as counseling, spiritual direction, or time off. Pro Tip: Ask each leader to share one personal development goal for 2025. This will help you support their growth and show your investment in their well-being. We specialize in leadership coaching for leaders in multisite churches. This past year we've coached executive level leaders and numerous directors. We can help you and your team as well. Interested? Let's talk. 3. Implement a Communication Plan for Vision Buy-In What it is: For your vision to take root in your church, it needs to be consistently communicated. A well-planned communication strategy will keep the vision in front of your staff, volunteers, and congregation, creating unity and excitement for what's ahead. Checklist: Plan a Vision-Casting Series or Sermon: Start the new year with a special sermon series that unpacks your church's 2024 vision. This gives you a platform to communicate key goals and inspire the congregation toward a shared mission. Use Multi-Channel Communication: Reinforce the vision through various channels: weekly emails, social media, video updates, and in-service announcements. Repetition across multiple platforms will help it stick. Equip Campus Pastors with Key Talking Points: Ensure that each campus pastor has a clear, consistent message to share with their campus. Provide them with talking points, vision documents, or visual aids that they can use to reinforce the vision with their own teams. Pro Tip: Use stories to make the vision come alive. Share testimonies from the past year and stories that illustrate how the vision impacts real people. Storytelling is one of the most powerful tools for gaining buy-in. This too is something ministryengine can partner with you in. One of our partners is a Senior Executive-level communications specialist and we have one of the best capital campaign experts on our team. Let's jump on a call. 4. Encourage Rest and Renewal for Staff What it is: After the intense holiday season, many staff members feel exhausted. Encouraging rest at the beginning of the year helps your team start strong and sets the tone for a sustainable, healthy pace throughout the year. Anticipate this. Checklist: Set an Example by Taking Rest Seriously: As the senior leader, model rest and balance by taking some time off yourself. Your team will follow your lead if they see you prioritizing your own health and boundaries. Consider a "Sabbath Week" for Staff: If possible, implement a week of limited work after Christmas or Easter to allow your team to recharge. This can be as simple as reducing non-essential meetings and giving staff a few days to rest. Encourage Personal Renewal Practices: Recommend personal renewal practices for your team, such as journaling, prayer retreats, or a digital Sabbath. Consider providing resources or reimbursements for these activities. Pro Tip: A rested team is a resilient team. If you can afford it, offer a small stipend for staff to use toward a retreat or personal renewal activity. It shows that you care about their well-being beyond their work. 5. Strengthen Team Culture and Build Momentum What it is: A healthy team culture is essential for sustainable ministry. Creating moments for your team to connect, celebrate wins, and stay aligned builds unity and keeps motivation high throughout the year. Checklist: Establish Regular Moments of Connection and Celebration: Schedule regular team gatherings to celebrate wins, share updates, and reconnect with the vision. These could be monthly staff meetings, quarterly retreats, or informal team lunches. Share "Quick Wins" Early in the Year: Identify some "quick wins" that your team can accomplish in the first quarter. These early successes will help build confidence and momentum for bigger initiatives. Foster a Culture of Open Feedback: Create an environment where team members feel comfortable sharing ideas, challenges, and concerns. Schedule regular feedback sessions or have an open-door policy to show that you value their input. Pro Tip: Consider implementing a simple "highs and lows" exercise during team meetings. This allows everyone to celebrate what's going well and express challenges in a supportive environment. In this past year we've done Team Dynamics workshops for senior executive teams, whole ministry departments, and individual teams at multisite churches. We can help your team build trust, awareness, and alignment at a retreat or onsite. Wrapping Up Part 3 Empowering your team is the final piece of the puzzle when it comes to finishing the year strong and setting up for success in 2025. By setting clear expectations, equipping leaders with the right resources, fostering open communication, and encouraging rest and renewal, you're building a strong and resilient team that's ready to bring your church's vision to life. The work of ministry is never done, but when your team is healthy, aligned, and empowered, you're able to move forward with confidence and joy. As you put these steps into practice, may you and your team experience the fulfillment of seeing lives transformed and communities impacted in new and meaningful ways. Thank you for following along with our 3-part series. Here's to a fruitful 2025 as you lead your church with clarity, purpose, and passion. --- ## Finish Strong, Start Fresh: Part 2: Cast Vision and Set Goals for 2024 with Clarity and Focus | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/finish-strong-start-fresh-part-2-cast-vision-and-set-goals-for-2024-with-clarity-and-focus/ id="main"> Finish Strong, Start Fresh: Part 2: Cast Vision and Set Goals for 2024 with Clarity and Focus Move from reflection to momentum. A checklist for refining vision, setting measurable goals, and aligning staff, budget, and stakeholders across every campus. By Nick Bogardus | Published 2024-10-21 | Updated 2024-10-21 In this season you and your team are probably spending a lot of time, energy, and resources preparing for your Christmas services. However, we want to remind you of another important opportunity you should balance in the mix. With the year-end audit behind you (from Part 1), it’s time to shift your focus from reflection to forward momentum. For multisite church pastors, casting a compelling vision and setting strategic goals are essential steps to leading your congregation well into the new year. In Part 2 of our series, we’ll walk you through a checklist to ensure you enter 2024 with clear direction, energized leadership, and alignment across all your campuses. 1. Refine or Reaffirm Your Values, Purpose, & Vision What it is: Your church’s organizational identity markers form the foundation for everything you do. We have a conviction that when you know who you are, you know what to do. Whether you're re-energizing your current vision or crafting new language to meet the moment, this is where your clarity of purpose begins. Checklist: Review Core Values, Purpose & Vision: Revisit your church’s values, purpose, and vision statements to ensure they still resonate with where God is leading your ministry. Does the language reflect your church’s heart and the changing needs of your congregation and community? Consider Cultural and Post-COVID Shifts: Reflect on how cultural changes and post-pandemic realities have affected your church. Does your current mission still speak to the needs of a hybrid congregation (in-person and online)? Set a Unifying Theme for 2024: You likely have an initiative you're calling people into. Choose a theme, scripture, or “word of the year” to rally your congregation toward. This theme will serve as a guiding principle that influences preaching, communications, and ministry focus throughout the year. Pro Tip: If you’re updating your values, purpose, or vision, communicate these changes to your staff first. Ensuring your leadership team is aligned with each of these is crucial for church-wide buy-in. 2. Begin to Consider Measurable Goals Across Ministry Areas What it is: Once your vision for next year is clear, it’s time to break it down into measurable goals for your ministries and campuses. These goals help translate vision into action and give your team clear objectives to work toward. Checklist: Attendance and Engagement Targets: Set specific goals for both in-person and online attendance at each campus. Consider not just numbers but also engagement. How are you moving people from attendance to active involvement? Financial Goals and Budget Adjustments: Review your current financial position and set giving goals for the new year. Make sure your 2024 budget aligns with your ministry priorities and vision. Consider key areas that need increased funding or where costs could be reallocated. Community Outreach and Impact Goals: Identify measurable outcomes for community engagement. This could include the number of people served, partnerships with local organizations, missions trips, or new outreach initiatives. How can you increase your impact locally and globally? Digital Ministry Objectives: If digital ministry has become a larger focus, set concrete goals for your online platforms. This might include improving live stream quality, growing online small groups, or reaching new geographic regions with your online presence. Pro Tip: Avoid setting too many goals. Choose a few high-impact goals and focus your energy there. It’s better to hit a few strategic targets than to spread your team thin across too many initiatives. 3. Assess and Adjust Staffing Needs What it is: Your vision and goals will only be realized if your staff structure supports them. This is the time to review your staffing model and ensure you have the right people in the right roles, with clear expectations and resources to succeed. Checklist: Review Staff Structure: Look at your current staff organization to see if it aligns with your values, purpose, and vision. Are there any gaps in leadership or areas where roles need to be redefined? Identify Staffing Gaps: Are there new positions needed to meet the goals of your vision? Consider whether you need to hire additional campus pastors, directors, or support staff. Update Job Descriptions: Make sure each staff member has a clear and updated job description that aligns with their goals for 2024. This creates accountability and helps each team member understand their role in advancing the vision. Evaluate Leadership Development Needs: Identify key staff members who need leadership development or new skills to thrive in their roles. Plan for intentional mentoring or training to help your team grow as leaders. Pro Tip: Conduct 1-on-1 meetings with key staff to clarify their goals for the year. This not only aligns them with church-wide priorities but also shows your personal investment in their growth. 4. Align Budgets and Resources with Strategic Priorities What it is: Your vision and goals mean little without the financial resources to back them up. Now is the time to make sure your budget reflects your highest priorities and that the necessary resources are in place to bring the vision to life. Checklist: Create a Draft Budget: Build a preliminary budget for 2024 that aligns with your ministry goals. Include projections for giving, staffing, programming, and facility needs. Reallocate Resources Where Necessary: Ensure that funding is allocated to the areas most critical to your vision. Are there underfunded ministries that need a boost? Are there programs that are no longer aligned with your mission and could be scaled back? Year-End Giving Push: If you’re close to year-end, consider a final giving campaign or communication to meet any shortfalls or start the new year with a surplus. Cast a compelling vision for why the congregation’s generosity matters as you prepare for 2024. Pro Tip: Consider a quarterly review of your budget and ministry goals with your leadership team. This allows for flexibility and ensures you’re staying aligned with your financial targets. 5. Engage Key Stakeholders in Vision and Goal-Setting What it is: For a vision to take root and flourish, your key stakeholders need to be fully bought in and aligned with the direction you’re setting for the new year. Whether it’s your board, campus pastors, or key volunteers, they should be part of the conversation. Checklist: Engage Your Board and Senior Leaders: Present the 2024 vision and key goals to your board and senior leadership team. Gather their input and ensure they are fully supportive before you move forward with the larger church body. Empower Campus Pastors to Cast Vision: Equip your campus pastors to share the vision with their own teams. Give them the tools they need (talking points, visuals, key goals) to communicate effectively and inspire their campuses. Hold a Leadership Vision Retreat: Consider hosting a January retreat or leadership meeting where your entire leadership team (staff and volunteers) gathers to align around the vision and goals for the new year. This is a chance to inspire, unify, and mobilize your leaders for the year ahead. Pro Tip: Create a simple and clear vision document or presentation that you can share with your leaders. This gives them a practical tool to help cast vision in their respective roles. Landing the Plane on Part 2 Casting vision and setting goals are some of the most powerful tools in your leadership arsenal. By taking the time to refine your church’s mission, set clear goals, and align your staffing and budget with your strategic priorities, you’re laying a solid foundation for success in the new ministry year. In Part 3, we’ll focus on equipping and empowering your team to execute the vision and hit the ground running in January. Remember, the most inspiring vision means little if your team isn’t equipped to bring it to life. Stay tuned for practical tips on building momentum with your leadership team and ensuring accountability as you move forward. --- ## Finish Strong, Start Fresh: Part 1: Year-End Audit for Greater Ministry Impact | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/finish-strong-start-fresh-part-1-year-end-audit-for-greater-ministry-impact/ id="main"> Finish Strong, Start Fresh: Part 1: Year-End Audit for Greater Ministry Impact A practical year-end audit for multisite pastors: review key metrics, campus health, your people, unmet goals, and your leadership team before the new year. By Nick Bogardus | Published 2024-10-14 | Updated 2024-10-14 In this season you and your team are probably spending a lot of time, energy, and resources preparing for your Christmas services. However, we want to remind you of another important opportunity you should balance in the mix. As we approach the end of the year, it’s a natural time to pause, reflect, and take stock of all that God has done through your ministry. For multisite pastors, this process isn’t just about personal reflection. It’s a chance to do a “year-end audit” across each of your campuses, ensuring you’re well-positioned to finish the year strong and lay a solid foundation for the new ministry year. In this first part of our 3-part series, we’ll walk through a practical checklist to assess where you are, celebrate what’s working, and identify areas that need extra attention. Let’s dive in! 1. Evaluate Key Metrics & Ministry Wins What it is: Numbers aren’t everything, but they do tell a story. Now is the time to review key metrics to understand how your ministry has grown and where there may be opportunities for improvement. Checklist: Attendance Trends: Review attendance growth at each campus, comparing in-person and online numbers. Are there sites that have seen strong growth? Sites that have stagnated or declined? Financial Health: Look at giving patterns and overall financial trends. Are you ending the year in a strong financial position? How does giving align with your budget goals? Volunteer Engagement: Assess volunteer retention and engagement rates. Is your volunteer base growing and thriving, or are there areas where you’re seeing drop-off? Community Impact: Look at measurable outcomes from your community outreach efforts: the number of people served, partnerships formed, or new outreach initiatives launched. Spiritual Growth Indicators: Track markers of spiritual growth, such as small group participation, baptisms, and first-time commitments. This is a chance to see the “fruit” of your ministry efforts. Pro Tip #1: Create a simple dashboard or summary document with these metrics so you can track year-over-year progress and easily share these highlights with your leadership team and congregation. Pro Tip #2: Be sure to delineate between inputs and outputs. For example, attendance and giving are inputs; percentage growth in Life Groups attendance, number of new deacons or elders, and percentage growth of first time givers are outputs. 2. Review Multi-Site Health What it is: Multisite ministry can amplify your reach, but it also introduces unique complexities. Reviewing the health of each site ensures alignment with the larger mission and allows you to identify specific needs. Checklist: Mission Alignment: Are all campuses aligned with the core mission and vision? Do they consistently reflect your church’s DNA? Campus Strengths and Challenges: Identify unique strengths and challenges at each location. Which sites are thriving? Are there any campuses that need additional support, resources, or even a strategic re-think? Consistency in Culture and Experience: Assess whether the experience is consistent across campuses. Are there gaps in worship quality, guest services, or children’s ministry offerings from site to site? Pro Tip #1: Consider having a brief meeting with each campus pastor to go over these questions. Their on-the-ground perspective will be invaluable for an accurate assessment. Pro Tip #2: A standardized review tool will help this process be as efficient and insightful as possible. 3. Celebrate and Recognize Your People What it is: Ministry is demanding, and often the people who pour out the most are the ones least recognized. An intentional approach to celebration can boost morale, reinforce your church’s values, and set a positive tone as you enter the new year. Checklist: Recognize Key Contributors: Make a list of key staff, volunteers, and lay leaders who have gone above and beyond this year. Consider public recognition or personal notes of gratitude. End-of-Year Gathering: Host a celebration event or staff retreat where you share ministry highlights, tell impactful stories, and celebrate what God has done. Congregational Stories: Share gratitude stories with your congregation to reinforce how their contributions have made a difference. Highlight stories that show the life change and impact your ministry is having. Pro Tip #1: This is also a good time to recognize campus-specific wins. Make sure each site feels that their unique contributions are valued and celebrated. Pro Tip #2: A presentation of these stories can become a great Year End Report for the church. 4. Identify Unmet Goals or Lingering Issues What it is: No year is without its challenges. Now’s the time to address any unmet goals or persistent issues that could hold you back if left unresolved. Checklist: Review Unmet Goals: Go over any goals from this past year that weren’t met. Why did they fall short? Are they still relevant for next year, or do they need to be modified? Address Lingering Issues: Identify any unresolved challenges, such as budget shortfalls, personnel gaps, or program misalignment. Document Lessons Learned: As you identify challenges, take time to document lessons learned. Use this as an opportunity for growth, not as a critique. What could you do differently next year? Pro Tip #1: Be open and honest with your team about these areas. Acknowledge where things fell short and frame the conversation around growth and improvement for the year ahead. Pro Tip #2: Take this to another level by having each ministry team conduct a SWOT assessment and present it to the executive team for awareness and feedback. 5. Conduct a Leadership Team Health Check What it is: The health of your leadership team has a direct impact on the health of your church. As the year closes, it’s crucial to check in on how your team is really doing, both collectively and individually. Checklist: Staff Satisfaction and Burnout Levels: Use an anonymous survey or personal check-ins to gauge overall morale. Are your staff showing signs of burnout, or do they feel supported and fulfilled? Communication Effectiveness Between Campuses: Evaluate how well your communication flows between campuses. Are there frequent misunderstandings or information gaps? Is everyone clear on expectations and direction? Leadership Pipeline and Succession Plans: Look at your leadership pipeline. Are there emerging leaders who need more development? Do you have succession plans in place for key roles, especially at the campus level? Pro Tip #1: If you’re not sure how to get honest feedback, consider bringing in a neutral third party to conduct an anonymous survey or facilitate a feedback session. Pro Tip #2: Does your leadership team have a list of potential leaders, deacons, or elders? This is a great time to compile that for the new year. Wrapping Up Part 1 Finishing the year with a thorough review not only helps you close any loose ends but also gives you a clearer picture of where God is at work in your ministry. This isn’t just an exercise in organization. It’s a way to celebrate the impact of your church, address obstacles, and ultimately strengthen the foundation for the year ahead. In Part 2, we’ll look at casting vision and setting goals for the new year, moving from reflection to forward momentum. Get ready to start dreaming big and creating a roadmap that aligns with your church’s mission and calling. --- ## The 4 Advisors: Architect, Builder, Banker, and Fundraising Expert | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/the-4-advisors-architect-builder-banker-and-fundraising-expert/ id="main"> The 4 Advisors: Architect, Builder, Banker, and Fundraising Expert Capital campaign readiness is a four-legged table. What the architect, builder, banker, and fundraising expert each tell you, and why you need all four. By Greg Gibbs | Published 2023-10-10 | Updated 2023-10-10 This post is an excerpt from Greg Gibbs' book, Capital Campaign Playbook. Greg has successfully led close to 200 capital campaigns in his career and is proud to work with the team at ministryengine. If you are looking ahead to a Capital Campaign, schedule your free consulting call today . Who are the parties you need to get ready for a Capital Campaign? Understanding readiness is like a four-legged table. Without each of these professional advisors weighing in, there may be a missing and critical component of leading the church well. Architects can answer, “How will we design something to meet our needs primarily and our wants secondarily?” Builders can answer, “When can we start, how long will it take and what will it likely cost?” Bankers can answer, “What will a financial institution lend us for this project should we choose to borrow either short or long term?” Fundraising experts can answer, “How much will the congregation likely give to a project like this and what is the best approach to engaging and motivating people?” People often ask: Don’t you have to design the project before you know the cost and whether or not it matches the congregation’s willingness to give? Answer: Not really. No matter what you design, it is against the odds that your congregation will defy the norm and go much beyond 3 times giving even if we were in the pre-2008 economy. So that becomes the top border (or highest level possible) if it were a cash only project. As we mentioned earlier, starting with 1.5 times income (in a three-year campaign) plus whatever lending the church is willing to service is a more fruitful conversation. Questions to Consider: Do we have the most helpful and necessary information and feedback from the four advisors mentioned above? What do we know so far? Are we willing to borrow money for our projects? Have we considered the gap between our project cost and our likely giving amount? Have we estimated the cash flow projection and how that may impact borrowing, start and end times, and more? In other words, when the congregation pledges X, it comes in over time (sometimes two or three years) and not in a lump sum. Another frequently asked question is “How much of the pledged amount can we expect to be fulfilled?” This is another statistic that doesn’t seem to be going in the right direction. When I first started coaching campaigns two decades ago, we would regularly see 90-95% of pledges fulfilled. Much of the industry talk these days is much more conservative and churches are encouraged to budget for 80-85% of total pledges unless a robust follow up process is executed. Chapter 17 highlights the effort that can be made in the post-pledge era of the campaign as a follow-up or follow-through on campaign promises and pledges. One way or the other, it is recommended that a cash flow projection be made to help with financial strategy and project completion timelines. For this post, I wanted to help you see that there are multiple parties needed to have a successful Capital Campaign. In subsequent posts we will continue to unpack each of the three phases (Discover, Design, and Disciple) to help you think through how God might lead you to steward the resources in your congregation. Book your free call today --- ## The Reality Check for Church Capital Fundraising Campaigns | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/the-reality-check-for-church-capital-fundraising-campaigns/ id="main"> The Reality Check for Church Capital Fundraising Campaigns How much can your church raise, and what will your people actually give? Assessing capacity and inclination before you design a capital project. By Greg Gibbs | Published 2023-09-19 | Updated 2023-09-19 This post is adapted from Greg Gibbs' book, Capital Campaign Playbook. Greg has successfully led close to 200 capital campaigns in his career and is proud to work with the team at ministryengine. If you are looking ahead to a Capital Campaign, schedule your free consulting call today . A vital part of the discovery process is assessing our reality. It is a look at our current data: the indicators of congregational engagement, involvement, and financial support. Why? Because the greatest predictor of future behavior is past behavior. We operate in faith and optimism, but we also have an eye on the numbers and ground ourselves in reality. It is recommended that church leaders assess both Capacity and Inclination. Looking at Capacity answers the most popular question a consultant hears when it comes to campaigns: How much can our church raise? And the idea of Inclination gets at the more difficult question to answer: What will our congregation actually give? Capacity In the capital campaign world, the church’s general budget revenue is used as a top-level predictive tool regarding the church’s capacity. In other words, if we are simply making an educated guess or general estimate, we start with the church’s annual operating revenue and then multiply that by some factor: 1 times that number, or 1.5 times, 2 times, or 3 times. Prior to the downturn of 2008-2010, the church capital campaign world was somewhat straightforward and fairly predictable: Church Operating Budget = X Capital Gifts Over Three Years = 2 or 3-times X When I was trained almost twenty years ago, the major capital campaign consulting companies for churches in America were groups like RSI, Cargill (for whom I worked in the early 2000’s), Injoy and a few others. And with rare exceptions, these companies would regularly lead churches to campaigns that resulted in double or triple the annual income in capital gifts over a three-year period. Things have changed. The dynamics in play before 2008 are very different than those today. The two most common stats are no longer the norm. Back in the day, most campaigns garnered at least 2 times general income and most campaigns were over a three-year collection period. It was clockwork. Like the Cubs never getting to the World Series. Well, that was then and this is now. These dynamics have shifted considerably. And just look at those Cubs! Current Trend: Churches are bold if they estimate that multi-year pledges will amount to anything larger than 1.5 times the church’s income Inclination Perhaps even more important than a congregation’s capacity to give is their collective inclination to do so. What this means is that a person or congregation may have a capacity to give X, but there is another factor in play: What are they likely to give to the project at hand? Not what could they give but what are they likely to give? Some projects tend to motivate people to give to their full capacity. Some may even cause people to stretch beyond what is comfortable as an act of faith. Others, not so much. Much of this is connected with the emotional tie-in and buy-in associated with varying aspects of church life. A part of it is connected with something tangible that we “get to see” when the money has been invested. This is why Debt or Dirt campaigns are the hardest to explain and connect with vision as well as people’s hearts. When we are retiring a mortgage or securing land, these are very important strategies for church life, but are just more difficult to create emotional support for. And this is why New Church Building or Sanctuary Renovation can garner lots of passion. It affects everybody in significant ways and is tied into our spiritual practices and places. Where would you rank your individual components or projects on a 1 to 10 scale, with 1 being “very difficult to gain emotional buy-in” and 10 being “easy to gain buy-in, people will be ecstatic”? My friend Rocky Miskelly is a passionate, life-long football fan of the University of Mississippi. He would explain the importance of understanding congregational buy-in by using football fans as an analogy as he talked about Ole Miss. He describes the difference between a “fan” and a “supporter” of the football team. A fan likes to cheer for the team and a supporter writes a check to fund the team. Just like a great college football program, you need both fans and supporters in the church. But it would be helpful to know who is in what classification before a major project is underway. Unfortunately, we have a hard time in church capital campaigns figuring out whether people will be fans of a capital project or supporters. And if they are supporters, to what degree will they be supportive? What is their sense of buy-in? Can we identify the biggest challenges we will face when asking people to fund this particular initiative? NOTE: The top-notch consulting firms will have a formal assessment tool that allows for a “test” of the congregation’s level of support during the planning phase so that church leaders don’t get surprised during the public phase (when it is often too late to make adjustments). The group at Aly Sterling Philanthropy offers the benefits of a formal study: Do I have a large enough donor base to support my goal? Does the project make sense and offer a concrete solution? Do I have the support of leadership? How much should we expect to raise? Is now the right time to host a capital campaign? What questions do potential donors have about the project? Who are potential major gift prospects/campaign leaders? Capacity Versus Project Cost I continue to be befuddled by churches that create wish lists and dream projects and spend time and money designing something they have no business designing. Not because churches shouldn’t dream or be creative, but because without some grounding in financial reality, it can burn up energy unnecessarily. Some churches really slow down progress by having to retreat from plans because they are way beyond the scope of what can be raised. Should we not have some sense of what our church is likely to give (and whether or not we are willing to borrow the rest) before we start designing with no financial parameters? If I were shopping for a house, a car, or budgeting for renovation in my personal life, I would start with the answer to the question, “How much can I afford to spend?” or “Am I willing to borrow money to renovate my kitchen?” Churches seem to get this in reverse order. I have met with more than a few churches that have an estimated cost for their project that is 4 or 5 times their annual budget or more. When I discover this, I hope and pray that the leadership has not been casting vision or creating excitement about a project that they will not be able to afford. If they have been talking it up, we are immediately thrown into a back-pedaling exercise before we can start a fund-raising campaign. Or the church will put itself into a position of borrowing more than they ever imagined. This undesirable outcome is the clear result of not gathering all of the necessary information to lead well. For this post, I wanted to help you see that there is more to a Capital Campaign than the public phase and introduce you to the Discovery Phase. In subsequent posts we will continue to unpack each of these three phases (Discover, Design, and Disciple) to help you think through how God might lead you to steward the resources in your congregation. Book your free call today --- ## Avoid Fuzziness: The Discovery Phase of a Capital Campaign (part 1) | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/avoid-fuzziness-the-discovery-phase-of-a-capital-campaign-part-1/ id="main"> Avoid Fuzziness: The Discovery Phase of a Capital Campaign (part 1) A capital campaign exposes every lack of clarity. Why the discovery phase starts with five irreducible questions, before anyone measures for curtains. By Greg Gibbs | Published 2023-09-12 | Updated 2023-09-12 This post is adapted from Greg Gibbs' book, Capital Campaign Playbook. Greg has successfully led close to 200 capital campaigns in his career and is proud to work with the team at ministryengine. If you are looking ahead to a Capital Campaign, schedule your free consulting call today . Where should you start the discovery phase of a capital campaign? The goal? The need? The strategy? Step one has to be gaining clarity. Being clear is uber-critical in any organization, especially in the church. The Cost of Being Fuzzy And if things have been fuzzy for a while about a church, its mission, its effectiveness, its future, its focus, or anything else, a capital campaign will expose that lack of clarity. There is nothing that exposes our organizational soft spots like a campaign. Members of the church will put up with being a bit in the dark regarding church leadership and their intentions most of the time. We love our church and for good reasons. But, when church leaders start to say things like, “Let’s pray about giving the largest gift we’ve ever given” or “Please consider supporting the church with a financial gift beyond your current support” all of a sudden people care deeply about clarity. They are asking themselves, “Why would I give even more to my church? What is so important that I should be praying audacious prayers about my increased giving? I’m not even sure I understand what’s going on anyway.” 5 Key Questions to Gain Clarity The discovery process in a campaign starts with clarity. It requires uncovering (or being honest about) how much clarity exists in our congregation. Do people know the answers to the five irreducible questions of clarity: What? Why? How? When? and Where? In other words, before we start measuring for curtains in the new fellowship hall, we need to find out if people know where we are headed. Some churches need a bit of a clarity “time out.” Before moving forward with a capital campaign, a church may need a time of refining and honing their vision and mission. Then, they may need to clarify and communicate this to the congregation. Then, and only then, will the congregation be ready to hear about projects that support that clear idea of a God-inspired future together. I recently worked with a church in Oklahoma who originally hired me to help them conduct a capital campaign. As we started to ask the Five Irreducible Questions, it became evident that capital improvements were the least of their concerns. With a senior pastor in succession, an aging congregation, a struggling second campus, and no clear understanding of the next steps for their organizational health, there was more murkiness than would allow for an effective campaign. We took a needed time out from campaign talk and began to chip away at their real need for organizational clarity and a focused plan for the future of their ministry. What about the generations? Another important aspect that is critical to understand is that many of our churches are still made up of people from several generations, including the Builder generation, of whom many are financially supportive of the church. Barna and other researchers have revealed the differences in generational views of “building buildings” as well as giving behavior in general. The over-representation of the Builder generation in the positions of leadership and influence often leads the church to equate progress with building construction. At the same time, so many churches are wondering why they aren’t connecting with the younger generations, Generation X and Millennial leaders. There are books written about this (this is not one of them) and this is an important pursuit when it comes to understanding the best direction for the church. Knowing the language and perspective of the generations in your church is critical. Some readers may need to put this book down and not consider pursuing a capital campaign until there is a better understanding of these dynamics and how they will play out at their church. Church leaders should have solid and clear responses to questions like: What is our vision for the future? Who are we and who are we becoming through God’s help? How will the projects being considered in this campaign help get us to that destination? When we have a sense of how much vision “equity” we have with the people, we will know better how to communicate the importance of the capital projects in light of that. For this post, I wanted to help you see that there is more to a Capital Campaign than the public phase and introduce you to the Discovery Phase. In subsequent posts we will continue to unpack each of these three phases (Discover, Design, and Disciple) to help you think through how God might lead you to steward the resources in your congregation. Book your free call today --- ## The three phases of a Church Capital Campaign | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/the-three-phases-of-a-church-capital-campaign/ id="main"> The three phases of a Church Capital Campaign The public ask is only one part of a capital campaign. An overview of the three waves: Discover, Design, and Disciple. By Greg Gibbs | Published 2023-09-03 | Updated 2023-09-03 This post is adapted from Greg Gibbs' book, Capital Campaign Playbook. Greg has successfully led close to 200 capital campaigns in his career and is proud to work with the team at ministryengine. If you are looking ahead to a Capital Campaign, schedule your free consulting call today . When people in the church mention a Capital Campaign, they are almost always thinking about one phase of it: the public phase. People remember or focus on that part because it is the part where church leaders are talking, preaching, praying, meeting, and conversing about the projects with the whole congregation. But there are actually multiple waves and a lot of work before we ever go public with asking for over-and-above financial contributions. In the pre-campaign waves, we are establishing our readiness as a church to enter a campaign. There is a good chance that if you are reading this, you are in that phase. At a very basic level, the inquiry starts with “How much does our project cost and will our people give that much?” Beyond the basic question is the idea that the preparation phase is as important (or more important) than the public phase. From due diligence to establishing appropriate targets to assessing congregational buy-in, this phase is where the greatest victories and mishaps may actually occur. Then, we realize there is still another level. For churches that want to conduct a discipleship-based campaign, we discover an extraordinary opportunity. The campaign can be a massive greenhouse for growing people’s commitment to Christ and their understanding of a life that is true life. This is why, in part, I'm passionate about this work. Because when there is thoughtfulness in regard to shaping the campaign, it can be an amazing experience filled with celebration and excitement instead of a dull but necessary endeavor dreaded by church leaders. The challenge is to aim for a best-case scenario: that faith in God and commitment to the church grow in a special and intense way. To meet this challenge, church leaders should pay attention to the process in three waves: Discover Design Disciple For this post, I wanted to help you see that there is more to a Capital Campaign than the public phase. In subsequent posts we will unpack each of these three phases (Discover, Design, and Disciple) to help you think through how God might lead you to steward the resources in your congregation. --- ## Navigating the Pastor Search Process: 9 Tips to Guide You to the Right Fit | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/navigating-the-pastor-search-process-9-tips-to-guide-you-to-the-right-fit/ id="main"> Navigating the Pastor Search Process: 9 Tips to Guide You to the Right Fit Nine practical tips for a pastor search: the committee, search firms, succession planning, job criteria, evaluation, character, and communication. By Nick Bogardus | Published 2023-08-19 | Updated 2023-08-19 The search for a new pastor is a pivotal moment in the life of a church. As church leaders, you understand the weight of this responsibility. Finding the right pastor who aligns with your congregation's values, vision, and mission is crucial for the future of your community. In today's dynamic landscape, where pastoral transitions can be accelerated by various factors, having a well-informed approach to the search process is paramount. This comprehensive guide is designed to assist church leaders like you in navigating the journey of finding your next pastor. From forming a search committee to partnering with a pastoral search firm, we will walk through the key considerations that will help you make an informed decision. Pastor Search Committee: Choosing Wisely The formation of a pastor search committee is often the starting point for many churches. While it's common to involve representatives from different ministries, consider the wisdom of having a spiritually mature and discerning team leading this process. Your search committee should consist of individuals who understand the complexities of pastoral leadership, the church's unique needs, and possess the ability to evaluate candidates holistically. This committee should reflect the spiritual heart of your congregation, ensuring that the new pastor resonates with the community's values and aspirations. Pastoral Search Firm: Expertise and Guidance For churches seeking a comprehensive and effective approach, partnering with a pastoral search firm can be invaluable. These experts offer not only a pool of potential candidates but also valuable insights into the search process. They understand the nuances of pastoral leadership, enabling them to match your church's requirements with the right candidates. With their experience, they can help navigate the pitfalls and challenges that often arise during a pastoral search. A firm like ours does all of the above with our distinctive, proven, boutique approach. Succession Planning: A Long-Term View Church leaders understand the importance of succession planning, especially in times of transition. The sudden departure of a pastor can leave a void that needs to be filled promptly and effectively. Consider evaluating potential successors well in advance, ensuring a smooth transition when the time comes. This strategy not only provides continuity but also demonstrates your commitment to the long-term growth and sustainability of your church. Defining Expectations: Job Description and Criteria To effectively find the right pastor, you need a clear job description that outlines both the essential qualifications ("must-haves") and the desirable qualities ("like-to-haves"). Use keywords like "Pastor Recruitment" and "Church Leadership Transition" to find examples or templates that guide you in crafting a comprehensive job description; you don't need to start from scratch. Consider the pastoral responsibilities required by your congregation, including preaching, pastoral care, leadership style, and community engagement. Strike a balance between academic qualifications, character traits, and the pastor's ability to connect with your church members. Evaluating Candidates: Objective Grid and Markers Having a standardized evaluation process is critical for objectively assessing candidates. Craft an evaluation grid that measures each candidate against predetermined criteria. Regular communication with the congregation helps manage expectations and keeps everyone engaged in the process. This transparent approach fosters a sense of involvement and support among your church members. This creates clarity for the hiring committee, congregation, and candidates and mitigates against an unclear, subjective process. Building Relationships: Pastoral Care and Connection In today's world, churchgoers are seeking pastors who can offer personalized pastoral care and connect on a deep level. You want effectiveness balanced with relational health. Prioritize candidates who demonstrate an ability to build meaningful relationships, connect with diverse demographics, and provide a sense of belonging to all members of your church community. Consider inserting relational elements to the process where you can observe how candidates interact with staff, congregants, and even baristas or servers. Leadership Qualities: Experience vs. Character The balance between pastoral experience and character is a critical consideration. While experience is valuable, character traits such as integrity, humility, and authenticity are equally, potentially more, crucial. Evaluate candidates based on their ability to lead, shepherd, and guide your congregation, recognizing that exceptional leadership qualities can outweigh years of experience. This is where checking references will serve you well. Optimal Committee Size: Collaboration and Efficiency A well-structured pastor search committee is key to effective decision-making. Larger committees might struggle to reach consensus, while smaller committees can be more agile and focused. A committee of spiritually mature individuals, rather than representatives from various ministries, can provide a well-rounded perspective that aligns with your church's vision. A set communication rhythm and aligned priorities for the role are vital here. Communication and Milestones: Staying on Track Incorporate a structured communication plan to keep the congregation informed throughout the search process. Regular updates help manage expectations, build excitement, and create a sense of unity among your church members. Schedule retreats or focused meetings for your search committee to deepen discussions and maintain momentum. Moving Forward As you embark on the journey of finding your next pastor, remember that this process is not merely about filling a position. It's about discovering a shepherd who will guide, inspire, and lead your congregation into the future. Whether you choose to form a dedicated search committee, partner with a pastoral search firm, or integrate succession planning, the goal remains the same: to find a pastor who aligns with your church's values, connects with your congregation, and is prepared to lead your community to new heights. Through diligent prayer, transparent communication, and a commitment to excellence, you can confidently navigate the challenges and opportunities that come with finding your next pastor. --- ## 7 Mistakes Churches Make When Hiring Staff | MinistryEngine URL: https://www.ministryengine.com/blog/7-mistakes-churches-make-when-hiring-staff/ id="main"> 7 Mistakes Churches Make When Hiring Staff Seven common mistakes that cost churches their best senior-staff candidates, with a practical tip for avoiding each one. By Nick Bogardus | Published 2023-08-04 | Updated 2023-08-04 It is getting increasingly more difficult to attract and hire qualified candidates to senior church roles. The process of staffing can be a delicate endeavor, and leaders may unknowingly make several mistakes that hinder their chances of attracting the best talent. We exist to help big-vision churches find long-term solutions and in our experience, these are some of the mistakes churches make that become obstacles to hiring and keeping the best candidates. Failing to Act with Urgency Time is of the essence when it comes to recruiting top-level talent. Delaying the process may result in losing excellent candidates to other opportunities. Demonstrating a sense of urgency in recruitment is essential. Be proactive and maintain responsive communication with candidates to create a positive experience. Tip: Once you are 70% confident in a candidate, proceed with booking a site visit to show your serious intent. Overanalyzing and Overinterviewing Excessive interviews and analyses can be overwhelming for candidates and lead them to question the church's culture. Instead, establish a streamlined process that doesn't overly burden candidates with needless steps. Have faith in your ability to make informed decisions after conducting realistic due diligence. Tip: Keep casual conversations and correspondence concise and avoid overwhelming candidates with administrative tasks. Always remember to center your discussions around your shared faith. Lack of Access to the Lead Pastor Top-tier candidates desire meaningful interactions with the key decision-makers, including the lead pastor. Even if the candidate won't be reporting directly to the lead pastor, make sure to provide opportunities for quality time between them. This interaction allows candidates to understand the church's direction and the lead pastor's influence on the church's culture. Tip: Facilitate a personal call or meeting with the lead pastor within a week of the candidate's positive initial encounter. Also, plan for additional personal time, such as sharing a meal, including spouses in the process. Neglecting the Person Behind the Resume While professional capabilities are crucial, valuing candidates as individuals is equally important. Take the time to get to know them personally and learn about their values, passions, and life experiences. This includes understanding their spouses as well. Tip: Ask insightful questions that get into their personal lives, such as their upbringing, life's proudest moments, major influencers, alternate career aspirations, and what drives them. Dwelling on Past Successes and Failures Leaders who focus excessively on the past may fail to inspire top talent. Instead, visionary and forward-thinking leaders are more likely to attract individuals who are enthusiastic about building both people and programs. Tip: Clearly define the church's vision and values in written documents, along with a detailed job description that sets the candidate up for success. Making Poor First Impressions Candidates often research churches before applying and expect to see authenticity and genuineness during interviews and site visits. Overselling the church's awesomeness and an overwhelming site visit schedule can exhaust candidates and negatively impact their perception. Tip: Plan ahead to manage first impressions thoughtfully. Include individuals with the right personalities who can connect with top-level talent genuinely and avoid resorting to hard-selling tactics. Involving non-staff individuals who share the church's values can also be beneficial. Setting Unrealistic Expectations Effective leaders understand that fostering a healthy work environment is essential for employee growth and success. Ensure that job descriptions are designed to help individuals thrive in all aspects of life. Tip: Hire exceptional individuals with specialized talents and allow them to excel in roles that align with their strengths. Ideally, at least 70% of their work time should be spent on tasks that align with their passions. By avoiding these seven mistakes and adopting an experienced, insightful, and concerned approach, your church can enhance its recruitment process and attract the best-suited individuals to build a thriving, healthy team.